How do we combat that?
Thought experiment: If we redistributed all the liquid capital that currently exists, one year later the people who own infrastructure will end up the 1% again.
You can see this through some basic economics. People have more money, they are willing to spend more money. Meanwhile, supply remains constant. What happens? Prices go up.
Everyone has to eat, everyone has to buy medicine, everyone needs to sleep, everyone needs the internet. Everyone “needs” to gamble. The people who own that infrastructure would be the richest again.
They have more power. Let’s say they get what they want. Double the working conditions and double the wage.
Now what?
Everyone needs to eat, needs to sleep. Ok let’s raise the prices. They can afford it. I.e they can no longer afford it.
Meanwhile, since food costs more so farmland costs more. Increasing barriers to entry.
So they strike and ... the cycle continues.
Basically, goods with the highest price elasticity of demand win. And they win by leaps and bounds.
We would first need to correct the monopolistic behaviors by corporations which is currently being encouraged by the US government. Then UBI would work.
OR
We could do a daily proportional wealth redistribution (i.e. UBI based on a percentage of total wealth, including assets, rather than a static number - and we could do this at a daily cadence). This system would hurt corporations which have goods of lower price elasticity of demand, but at least it would be good for individuals.
OR
We could have it as state run/sponsored, i.e. the government runs farms and sells food, or companies run food production and sales, but the government pays for it. This has quality concerns, especially when it comes to regional distribution. But hopefully, like the US schooling system, maybe a combination of both government run, and government sponsored (i.e. charter school), and privately run (i.e. for the ultra wealthy), would create a healthy enough environment. Ideally, since this doesn't depend on the quality of local teachers (i.e. food doesn't care if it is getting re-allocated to rural Arkansas), it would work out better than the US schooling system. Note: This doesn't work as well for housing.
"Why do you need a raise? You get $xxx in basic income." - Boss
Salaries (except maybe minimum wage) are set by demand and supply. UBI will do nothing to demand, will do nothing to supply of high skilled jobs and may actually reduce supply for low paying jobs by providing an alternative that isn't starving.
Even today I could spend 3x less on rent if I moved and endured a 30min commute. I don’t. Having a job is not the primary priority for why I’m paying high rent.
Maybe read up a bit on fiscal multipliers. Government spending (redistribution) is one of the better ones. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fiscal_multiplier
Also, worker productivity is through the roof. Perhaps we can talk about giving back some of those production gains, if it funds things we like.
Citation/explanation needed. I don't see it working out this way – that seems like a dramatic simplification of the economics at play.
GDP is a very rough indicator for a society's standard of living and well being. GDP is really bad at measuring things like health, household productivity, technology changes, education, leisure, environment, etc - all which may not show up in GDP.