We should just get rid of the public domain exception and recognise intellectual property as normal everyday property, not something that can magically becomes ownerless one day. Communism has been tried and it doesn't work. Let's not repeat the mistakes of the past.
On the other hand, I do hear the plight of preservationists &c. There should be a lot more rights granted to people to use copies of other people's property. For starters, all non-commercial use should be allowed, so that old movies could be digitised and stored in better formats. After all, the studio doesn't own the tape or the DVD that contains the movie, it owns the movie itself and the type of media it's stored on shouldn't matter. This probably would also mean that noncommercial free peer-to-peer filesharing would also be legal, but honestly, if you can't compete with torrent sites, which blast thirty porn popups and show you a dozen false download links, your business probably deserves to die.