If you're worried about living too long you can buy an annuity. It makes no sense for employers or the government to make that choice for you.
Not everybody has family to fall back on in retirement, but we still don't want to let them simply die. So the money has to be given somewhere.
I see no real alternative to freedom here. Let people make their own choices. Over the long term you can't really conjure up better investment returns and better retirements for people by decree. The wealth has to be there.
If not, the running out of money part happens either way.
I think you are confusing pensions with social security. Social security already provides that bare minimum mandatory safety net.