> Should I be forced to hire a neo-nazi or a terrorist sympathiser so long as they're up to the job?
Just like you should be "forced" to hire a Greenpeace member, or a union organizer, or someone outspokenly pro-choice, or someone outspokenly pro-life, or someone running on the libertarian ticket, or someone running on the Communist ticket.
How this would play out in practice if someone "brought their politics to work" and the case went to court, I can't tell you; I'm not an expert in California labor law. But if people aren't bringing their politics to work, firing people for political views would be an even more concerning precedent, to me.
(In Damore's case, the politics was very much brought to work, and not just by him. I make absolutely no claims about what that means in terms of the above-cited law, or morality, for that matter.)
What Damore may be trying to do is establish a legal understanding that the political discrimination (which definitely happened) was connected to racial discrimination (which would need to be proven in court). If Damore can do that successfully, he should be able to win the lawsuit.
But I don't think it's possible. At least it shouldn't be possible. Like you suggested, companies must be able to discriminate against political behavior at work that is disruptive.
Damore's memo was released in an unruly manner that disrupted Google's bottom line. It also brought down company morale, alienated fellow coworkers, and caused undue internal strife. His resulting unwillingness to help contain the drama demonstrated his lack of allegiance to the company's interest. Behavior like this cannot be protected from termination.
The person who leaked it to vox should be on the chopping block.
However, the death threats and misrepresentations of his text were not simply a factor of it being published globally. From what I have heard, the discussion was already heated inside of Google before it even got leaked.
Also, I don't think Damore was ignorant to the fact that his content was divisive in nature. I think he knew exactly what he was trying to say and knew what kind of reaction it would provoke.
I really think he needs to own it, and the lawsuit just proves the point to me why he was fired. He's not a "team player"; can't own up to his mistakes. Sure, perhaps this lawsuit will make it easier for people to discuss politics in the workplace without being fired, but his actions telegraph his intent, at least to me.
This has been about "social politics" from the beginning.
It is illegal to prevent people from engaging in politics, in California.
This suggestion is illegal.
California law is extremely pro employee.
Google obviously has a lot of reasons to fire Damore but they do not even need a reason.
Former Google engineer sitting at home unemployed and unable to find a job supports he should have been fired.
And google definitely didn't fire him for no reason.
It is illegal to engage in "Forbidding or preventing employees from engaging or participating in politics or from becoming candidates for public office."
Here is the california law in question:
http://leginfo.legislature.ca.gov/faces/codes_displaySection...
If there are smoking gun emails that say "We are going to fire him for his politics", then Google broke the law.
All this information will come out during the lawsuit, and during discovery, if it exists.
I put political in quotes back there simply because it's a word that can be bent in all sorts of directions to mean anything from Politics to simply having an opinion on something. Remember, the opinion might be highly offensive and make working with others, on a team, more difficult.
I'm no lawyer, but I don't see how this would make any difference.
Consider that a black man in rural Mississippi in the 1960s would have had a very difficult time serving white patrons at a restaurant; I don't think "people didn't like him working for us" is a viable defense here.
But here it is so black and white on firing him this entire discussion is a bit ridiculous. The entire thing is some weird PR thing driven by the right wing.
Any company I am familiar with in the US would have fired Damore. It is also why nobody will hire him.
It is also why he now has his GF filter him.
In California, however, political affiliation is a protected class under state law.
That's not what happened here, though.
> CA is a right-to-work state, isn't it? Anyone can be laid off at any time.
You're confusing "right to work" and "at will". "Right to work" means that it's illegal for a union to prohibit non-union workers. "At will" means that employers can fire people without reason.
Even in an "at will" state, there are protected classes under both federal and state law. Political affiliation is not a protected class under federal law, but it is under California state law.
Google explicitly fired the guy for the memo. They aren't hiding as for why they fired it they explicitly gave the reason.
If you explicitly give a reason for why someone is fired, and that reason is illegal, them you will lose the court case.
Similarly, you could also find someone hiking in the woods, and just shoot them or something, and you might get away with it. Or you might not.
That's how the law works.
Google has been very clear as for why the guy was fired. Now the only question is is their stated reason equivalent to firing someone for politics. And if so, that's illegal.
This is very different in the US versus other parts of the world.
But here it is pretty easy because ANY company I am familiar with in the US would fire Damore. It is just how things work in the US. You do not write what he wrote and share it. Might not be fair but how things work.
It is also why he is sitting at home and nobody will hire him. All of this has ZERO to do with politics and him being right leaning.
The issue has been cop-opt by the right wing to use it to gen up their base.
This is NOT a political issue as it appears you think. Writing what he did about women is NOT political. It is just human decency and something you just do not do.
Why do you think he now has his GF filter what he writes?
It is illegal to prevent someone from "engaging" in politics, as per the California law I just linked you.
It is not legal to fire someone for "basically any reason" if it was for the illegal reason that I have linked.
Maybe what he did does not count as politics. You could make that argument.
But your argument about how it is possible to fire someone for any reason is untrue, as per the law.