[Edit: By disrespectful I mean actually harassing people (at least in the Japan videos). That's a valid cause for banning in most communities]
[Edit: By disrespectful I mean actually harassing people (at least in the Japan videos). That's a valid cause for banning in most communities]
Free speech is not something that private companies need to protect as far as the law goes, but I think it's an ideal that they should try to hold dear nonetheless, as much as possible. "Acted disrespectfully towards a group" is way too wiggly and subjective as an offense to start banning people over.
Edit: just to be clear, I think the suicide video is clearly over the line. I'm only talking about his general shithead-ness the rest of the time.
Does demonetization mean "banned" to you?
From participating in a private online community that doesn't want people peeing in the pool? Sure. Harm done to Paul in exchange for others' benefit. Seems like an easy choice.
By allowing this content YouTube is defacto endorsing it which then encourages others to follow in his footsteps. "All that is necessary for the triumph of evil is that good men do nothing."
Never mind that a global platform like YouTube has an impossible tension of thousands of subcultures, countries, advertisers and other stakeholders to try and balance.
That’s the big mistake of these Web 2.0 platforms in my opinion - they try to be both a virally growing platform and a community but always wait until something bad happens before making the rules apparent. It’s an unresolvable problem in my opinion.