Chill The F*% out over the Google/Verizon Proposal
seanoc.com
seanoc.com
You know how when Apple does something unsavory to further its own business interests, and Apple fans spin the most elaborate arguments to show how Apple doing what's best for Apple is actually in everyone's interest? This is your chance to be different.
I've never seen a piece of regulation done by government that actually worked, quite the contrary, because of government interventions many monopolies/oligopolies are possible.
Only monopolies can act in anti-competitive / anti-consumer ways, and without them you wouldn't need regulation in the first place.
Customers want to watch Youtube and contrary to popular belief, costumers aren't stupid ... they just sometime don't care enough ... but they will care once that video from Youtube can't be viewed in HD although they have an (advertised) 20 Mbps line ... and they'll also know whom to blame.
And you know why, because everybody knows an information Maven that will explain to them why their current ISP sucks, and they also know Connectors that will spread this information to other people (yeah, it's called a viral effect through word-of-mouth ... in the real world; it's quite efficient ... the American revolution started that way ;)).
This is the way the free market always worked ... and government regulation is just fixing the symptoms rather than the disease.
As I've said in another thread regarding wireless Internet ... in my country there are not one, but 3 3G Internet providers ... all of them announcing new offers on a monthly basis. 2 of them have pre-pay options and to be honest I've never seen so much competition.
So why the fuck should government step in and regulate that?
You want to keep the Internet free? Then fucking work towards preventing monopolies.
Fundamentally, this is an issue of trust. The deal Google is proposing creates significant wiggle room for the landline carriers, and asks us to trust that the issue will be revisited for wireless carriers somewhere down the road, even though an entrenched discriminatory regime will be much more difficult to dislodge if it becomes a reality on the ground. There is a fairly strong net neutrality movement today, even without Google, an apparently sympathetic FCC, and a Democratic Congress capable of passing a net neutrality bill. There will not be a better opportunity to legislate net neutrality for years, given the likely results of the upcoming midterms. Google is asking us to trust them and wait, when waiting will almost certainly put the enemies of net neutrality into a stronger position.
Personally, I don't see a lot of reason to trust Google on this issue. They are like a lifelong Republican who suddenly discovered the attraction of left-wing politics after losing his primary and joining the Democrats.
"Congress rebukes FCC on Net neutrality rules" http://news.cnet.com/8301-13578_3-20005834-38.html
"In theory, most Democrats favor Net neutrality. But theory doesn't always mesh with political practice. Rank-and-file Dems are clamoring for Net neutrality about as much as Bush-era Republicans were clamoring for limited government: it's a valuable talking point, but of course there's no need to do anything hasty. (Besides, even in this anti-incumbent year, how many single-issue Net neutrality voters are there?) The last time there was a major rewrite of telecommunications laws, it took something like five years for Congress' internal mechanisms to spit out the Telecommunications Act of 1996. A push for national cable franchising legislation went on for years but died without a vote."
Either use fuck, or don't. If you don't want to use the word fuck, then use another word. It's easy to be equally harsh. "Chill the hell out about the Google/Verizon proposal." "Freaking out about the Google/Verizon proposal? You're a retard."
The point of censoring is that it's externally imposed. Swear filters on poorly designed multiplayer video games. Internet forums. When you self-censor, you announce that you spend so much time in such places that it has irrevocably altered your writing.
Instead, we get cries of Google running afoul and that (somehow) every intellectual person at Google is now "evil" and bent on world domination.
They lost any pretense of idealism when they expanded into China. That was a tough moral call. So was this. Some moral calls are tough to make, and maybe Google made the wrong calls, but there's a difference between "don't be evil" and "be idealistic and pure and unquestionable in your motives, and when it comes to the hard questions, just punt on them".
There are strong arguments both for and against net neutrality, and Google did itself a disservice by trying to rally people behind the idea that net neutrality is the "good" option and anything else is "evil". That sort of simple binary good/bad is reminiscent of George W. Bush's approach to selling people on his war strategy.
The fact is, it doesn't matter whether we have laws enforcing net neutrality... for most things a neutral net is what consumers expect and demand. For the marginal things where consumers don't care (possibly including internet search) then consumers still win.
The fact that everyone on the internet reads the NYT and Gawker (and Gawker just reports on NYT reports) lead to some sort of vicious rabble-rousing feedback cycle. The power of the media.
(thank you Louis c.k.)
Not that I have a problem with the word 'fuck'; just that it's not really appropriate for most serious discussions.
Also many forget that Verizon is the company owning the pipes and spectrum, not Google, and as much as it's unpleasant to think about, NN won't be put into law without teleco input.
In this case, its reasonable to wonder if Google has changed from champion of NN to a company that sees its next great revenue pool (mobile) forming before its eyes.
Because to my euro eyes it seems like US fanboys cheering on Apple, iPhones and AT&T, which makes Google, Android and Verizon the "baddies" in this tag team match. And yet you get Android phones on all carriers, including AT&T, and the iPhone seems to be coming to Verizon (and I assume all other carriers once exclusivity is broken, like in many other countries) so these "teams" are basically fiction.
So where's the real beef here?