It's very easy for a single admin with a single machine to provide 4 nines to a small group with a small load. But this usually scales exponentially.
Tech stuff isn't hard. The biggest problem is the lack of capacity planning and project communication in tech today. Nimble startup is a euphemism for pure anarchy and chaos. No one wants to plan anything any more.
Cloud services are not efficient or cheap, they're convenient for the unprepared and haphazard management style that VC's love.
You may still disagree in the end, but you should come to the conclusion that it is not categorically stupid for some companies to choose to pay much more over time so that they can pay a lot less right now.