If we are trying to measure some kind of mental ability as a predictor to work performance, one might question whether interviewer ability to extract such deeper insights from these questions is actually more effective than a g test.
If we are trying to measure some kind of mental ability as a predictor to work performance, one might question whether interviewer ability to extract such deeper insights from these questions is actually more effective than a g test.
I would probably not give this question in an interview, but if I did, I'd care a lot more about how the interviewee reacted to it than about getting the right answer. The people I want to work with are people who respond to weird questions with curiosity, not with guesses and a lack of followup. For a question that presumably would only take a few minutes to ask, it's decent enough. A bad question would be one that by design gives no information (or worse, gives misleading information), and this question does better than that.
Am I guaranteed to learn about their curiosity? No. In particular, candidates who are very nervous are more likely to clam up than start teasing out the details of the question. That's unfortunate, but hopefully this isn't your only interview question so there are still other opportunities for the candidate to show their stuff.