A package management solution is probably better for server environments, but I don't really think it should be necessary for desktops.
You insist there is no need for package management because you never had real package management. The Macintosh method is very simple (much better than the Windows way) but it fails miserably when what you are installing is not an application.
However, I do agree the method "fails miserably when what you are installing is not an application." MacPorts and Fink are decent solutions, though I admit they could be much better.
For every duplicated library, you introduce the security and stability problems of that specific version, each will have to be addressed by the application provider, who may or may not be interested in the latest developments in the libraries it uses, instead of the original software developer. This thing can grow nasty in no time.
Certainly many applications can just be dropped in the Applications folder, and I admit this is a great feature. But I still have to go out and get updates to those programs, and not all can be installed or removed as easily as moving the application folder. With a package manager, it auto-updates every program for security updates and sometimes bug fixes. If I add the repository for that particular application, it automatically gives me new versions when they come out. Everything is in one place. Furthermore, I can search for software that does a particular task and be presented with several choices that are just a click away.
I'm glad OS X works best for you, but for my needs and uses, Ubuntu is a far superior choice.
Yes. That and dependency management are the towering wins of package management. Installing an app when you first get it is generally the easy part of managing it.