Teamsters Tell UPS: No Drones or Driverless Trucks
wsj.com
wsj.com
Seriously, do the teamsters not realize that if they cripple UPS's ability to compete that they'll just all be out of a job suddenly when UPS gets destroyed in the market? They need to figure out how humans can actually add value relative to the other options and implement those changes. They need to figure out how to long-term keep humans relevant to the delivery industry. These sorts of short-term hacks by the parasite will just kill the host.
If and when competitors have it and start hurting UPS's business, the teamsters may relax the request. What UPS should do is make sure the contract allows them to still do R&D and small-scale trials. If and when a competitor comes along that is a serious threat to UPS's business, the teamsters will probably relax the production-based automation clauses.
It's a compromise I think both sides would agree to. After all, they don't want to kill the hand that feeds them. The only actual thing UPS is sacrificing is being first-to-market with such automation. Just be ready to be 2nd.
Can't really add 'value' when there's aren't any jobs that needs to be filled. Alot people are going to be displaced in the following years and we must remember these people are moms, fathers, brothers, sisters, etc. They are not just statistics to be discussed.
It would be great if there were more tech news of giving people jobs instead of taking them away.
I don't think any of the individuals want to be a parasite. I think they want to be valuable and rewarded for the value they add.
There's nothing wrong with wanting to live a normal modest life with a normal paycheck that lets you raise a family, buy a house, etc. I think that's all most people want.
The only way that is possible, though, is if one adds value to the company or organization one works for. If you actively harm the company or organization, your value is negative, and you are actively killing the organization that is distributing paychecks.
I blame the union for short-sighted thinking, not the individual workers for wanting job security.
Maybe that's a bad biological analogy... can you think of a better one? It seems like if an individual or group of individuals in an organization are not useful, but want to keep receiving benefits... well, the closest analogy I could find is maybe a leech or tapeworm or something like that. Maybe an appendix or a whithered arm?
Maybe I'm being uncharitable, but that won't change the reality of what happens when the business is outcompeted and everyone is out of a job. The union cannot create a company - only provide some protections against certain classes of management decisions. Once there is no management because there's no company, the union will die. :-/
And I am now questioning where's your humanity.
Would you be saying the same thing if your mom or dad was in the said union?
I don't expect you to see eye to eye but I want to say progress at the expense of people's lives isn't something to be proud of.
You know what would be great?! If we could make poverty obsolete or even just hunger. There's going to be alot of people in that situation because of this.
Maybe your too high in your ivory tower to see it.
If you think the analogy is inaccurate, I invite you to explain how what the union is doing is _not_ parasitic, rather than making emotional appeals.
I think that progress at the expense of people's lives _isn't_ progress. I think progress is the improvement of people's lives. I think that the union policies will harm people's lives, which is why I'm opposed to it.
This type of progress is only going to put alot of people out on the street and make the rich richer.
They are not parasites to the company because the company runs better with people running it.
Simplifying a union's relationship to a company as a value proposition is asinine. There's a bigger picture that must be looked at.
People are more important than machines. Even if we fight alot.
What if in a few years for 80% of the people there will be now way they can add value to companies? Let them rot in the gettho's? Is that the society you want?
https://www.cnbc.com/2018/01/24/labor-teamsters-want-to-ban-...
That said, companies do need to look at the morality of automating jobs away. Is there a social contract between companies and the population they serve? In a world where new jobs replaced old, the contract remained intact, in some form, but if now it's outright elimination without adding transformed jobs, there will likely be a breakdown.
1. A robot arm using cameras, sensors, and a AI neural network, will unload a truck, and put it on the conveyor belt.
2. Then the same AI robot arm will load a truck.
I predict that in the future, a delivery guy will drive his van to your neighborhood, where he will have 5 deliveries to make. He will drive to the center of all the customers. Then, 5 robotic dogs, will take the package to each of the 5 customers.
The robotic dog will scan the customer, get a face recognition for authorization, and a confirmation for hand-off.
Meanwhile, the delivery guy is sitting in his car twittling his thumbs, waiting for the robotic dogs to come back. Ten minutes later, the robotic dogs come back, they charge back up in their docking stations, and the driver goes off to his next destination.
The delivery guy will only be used to deliver extra bulky items, that the robotic dogs cannot yet handle. But future robotic dogs will be able to handle all kinds of bulky packages.
In 15 minutes, 5 packages got delivered. At a rate of 3 minutes a package. This is incredible, and it will allow UPS to increase their package delivery throughput.
Or, the driver will just drive closer to each of the customers. The robotic dog will deliver the package, while he drives to the next customer on the list. And when all packages are delivered on that route, then he'll come back and pick up each robotic dog, as they sit there waiting.
If the unions stop UPS from automating, then they're going to kill themselves. Another company will take over, and their robotic fleet will put UPS out of business.
They'll call themselves, the Robo Delivery Express (RDX).
And for some other scenarios, drones are going to start aerial delivery. These are more practical for suburban houses with a large front yard. You will need at least a 10x10 sqft area for aerial drone delivery. A mid-sized drone will fly to your house, and hover over the delivery point.
You will use your smartphone to authorize the hand-off. The drone gets the authorization to proceed. Cameras using an AI neural network, will scan the area to confirm safety, before initiating the delivery sequence, to make sure all is clear. Then a winch will wind down and gently put the package on the ground. Wind back up, take a last visual scan to make sure all is well, and then fly away.
The future is robotic. It is inevitable.
For the majority of packages and deliveries, it could be completely automated. Anything bulky or non-standard would either be a separate delivery, or require pickup.
I think Amazon will be in this space first; heck, it might be most efficient (not energy-wise, of course) to just deliver the packages ad-hoc from the warehouse; imagine if their warehouse robots could leave the warehouse and deliver the package immediately - perhaps as soon as your order is completed!
They already have the standard-sized packaging for most things; they'd just need "standard-sized robots" for the delivery to handle the packages.
Or - in some far-off future that probably won't occur - imagine if the packaging boxes were the robots...
I say this, but in the long term we should also be discussing what a "post-work" economy looks like when the machines ultimately take over everything and there is nowhere left to run...
The companies dabbling in automation are doing it to cut costs. They—at a minimum—need to recover their R&D spend. The utopian view that automation instantly makes everything cheaper doesn't stand up when you consider the fact that our global productivity keeps rising while wages remain stagnant - it's easy to see where all that saved money goes.
I agree with you fully, but it's going to take some radical government policy to raise enough money to fund these sorts of programs. It's very unfortunate.
However there is a cost, and long term it will be the ability to provide increasingly huge numbers of people with a job that can provide a reasonable standard of living, along with bread on the table and a roof over their heads.
At some point the huge majority "without", will act to regulate out of control change and enterprise which is not to their benefit, or that of their children. Revolution is not just a quaint concept limited to the past.