In the cash equities markets?
Maybe 15 years ago. But in the past 10+ years, you have to have the shares to short or you get in "alot of trouble.".
What you are describing is straight up illegal and no prime broker will allow this.
I get that you probably don't work in the markets and you are relaying on something you read, don't feel too bad, there is alot of mis-information about wall street out there :)
And nope, not relying on something I've read but experienced runing a public company as founder and CEO: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13844765
To put it another way, let’s say you are shorting gold, but your counterparty won’t accept a piece of paper. They want delivery, like an actual gold bar. That gold bar has to come from someone who now has one less.
No, it isn’t. Brokers certify ownership through official channels. Lying about a customer’s account is fraud. In the repo market, that is investigated directly by the Federal Reserve. Naked repos aren’t a thing.
Does that mean that you think that it doesn't happen?
It happens, but it’s rare, at least with repos. Treasuries are tracked by the CUSIP—the U.S. Treasury knows every nominal owner. Being short-term, settled up front and centrally tracked makes it a bad place to attempt fraud.
Fraud is a frequency, not binary, metric. Fraud in crypto-currencies is rifer than anything we’ve seen in America for generations. Complaining about potential repo fraud when BitConnect and pump and dumps run rampant is a bit silly.