Hacker News Reader

Is it not possible there's just a security violation they need to sort out?

Am unfamiliar with Puffin, but the post leaping straight to "it's a conspiracy!" without indicating what the stated rationale for rejection was appears a bit off.

(I'd I'm normally first in line to attribute things to corporate greed)

View on HN

Their medium article explains the reason apple rejected them. They use chromium on their servers to render pages. Apple wants them to use webkit.

If this is really the case it’s nonsense that an iOS policy would extend into your servers too.

The problem isnt that its serverside, its thats a different renderingengine, and therefor visually could/is rendering differently than safari/webkit.

Who cares?

There are tons of games in the App Store with custom user interfaces that don’t match anything from Apple.

Thats not the issue, the issue is that cnn or whatever.com might render differently or not at all if viewed in one browser, instead of the other. I dont know the internals of puffin, but security and js attack vector, might be different as well.

You said "and therefor visually could/is rendering differently than safari/webkit"

You didn't say anything about security, but there is no security problem either.

The client side wouldn't be evaluating JavaScript outside of Apple's JS engine so there is no security risk whatsoever.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com