Montana to FCC: You can’t stop us from protecting net neutrality
arstechnica.com
arstechnica.com
I was a bothered by the down-voting of a block of 13 comments although Moderator Dang was right to tag the comments as "shallow" and "partisan" and, therefore, inappropriate, since they stray substantially from the topic at hand.
Claiming “state’s rights” is therefore never more than a convenient argument when you want to avoid the substance of the issue. And if that substance is racist, you are likely to be called a racist no matter what.
If people with different views are concentrated in different areas, we can maximize total democracy (i.e. representation of citizen's opinions in government) by allowing them to pick their own local laws.
This over constrains "legalization" to a single dimension. Cannabis is a difficult policy space, marrying the complexity of liquor laws with the harm reduction imperatives of medicine and drug policy.
Sample: medical versus recreational standards, personal limits (if any, and if so, what?), tax levels (quantity? dollar amount?), where to apply the taxes (consumer, retailer, distributor, and/or grower?), constrain grower or distributor size (+: more independent shops, -: higher costs), give this to alcohol regulators or create a new regulatory umbrella, what about the cash (state-chartered bank or credit union? criminality and money laundering concerns?), monitoring adolescent usage, risk education, heavy metals monitoring, et cetera.
But I firmly believe that most laws of governance should be state and local so there is choice, reasonable chances for an individual to effect change, and a lower bar to experiment with policy.
So, no, being a racist bigot trying to justify the civil war by trotting out "states rights" still gets you labeled as such.
But yes, it's rich irony seeing the states raising these issues.
Decentralised decision making is a large component of the American system’s resilience. At its worst, it’s a pressure release valve which shows us the negative effects of bad policy in a controlled setting (e.g. North Carolina’s bathroom bill). At its best, it promotes policy experimentation which can later scale, having been demonstrated to work, to the national stage (e.g. California’s clean air rules).
Also, could you please take the following guideline to heart in the future? "Please respond to the strongest plausible interpretation of what someone says, not a weaker one that's easier to criticize." Not doing so leads to the bottom of the barrel, and we're trying to do a bit better than that here.
Also, the site guidelines ask people not use uppercase for emphasis: https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html.