But since the biggest market for this is money laundering, it's hard to imagine any "legit, fully transparent, US based companies" succeeding.
Disclaimer: I own some bitUSD, bitCNY, BTS, but I am not involved in other ways with the project.
[1] https://wallet.bitshares.org/#/asset/USD
And furthermore, how is the web comic artist going to pay their rent? Landlords don't take tethers, so at some point they need to cash out to actual dollars and receive an ACH transfer from an exchange or the like. Are they really better off being forced to trust a crypto exchange?
And since the pitch is “we want anonymous international depositors to open and close accounts with you,” with extra steps added, no bank will agree.
But there is the need for everyone to trust the ETF manager. Authorised participants (APs) must trust they can redeem ETF units for a basket of the underlying shares and vice versa. Other market participants, in turn, must trust that process to manage tracking risk.
ETF managers earn that trust by contractually guaranteeing APs' creation/redemption rights, being regularly audited like normal companies, being regulated like securities companies, and having their holdings vouched for by other market participants, e.g. banks, clearing and settlement services, et cetera. Literally none of the preceding apply to Bitfinex nor Tether.
More broadly, a structure like Tether is inherently incompatible with anti-money laundering. No jurisdiction will let a bank say "these $2 billion are held by unknown beneficial owners." If we wanted that, we'd just re-authorise numbered, i.e. anonymous, bank accounts.
[1] https://www.bankdirector.com/index.php/magazine/archives/2nd...