U.S. senators ask consumer watchdog head for details on Equifax probe
reuters.com
reuters.com
I just finished in it a discussion of Enron and their auditors, Arthur Andersen. The justice department prosecuted Andersen (one of the "big 5" accounting firms at the time), and there was a lot of backlash about the Justice Dept "killing Andersen".
The details of it are that Enron was way crooked, lying to investors and the public saying everything was great, when it wasn't. Andersen audits didn't reveal this, and also was responsible for increasing document shredding from 80lbs/day to >2,000lbs/day in the few days before the SEC subpoena. And this was after Andersen had been shown to be negligent in the auditing of Worldcom, QWest, and Globalcom.
Basically, they recommended fraudulent practices with WorldCom, got caught and said "We promise we will never do that again" and did it again with Enron.
Justice Dept prosecuted, and then there was all this backlash about the prosecution.
So, is prosecution of Equifax likely? Seems like we as a country have trained the government not to.
Equifax is largely embedded in our business/credit infrastructure and there would be collateral consequences for all of the businesses who would have to change as a result of their punishment/demise. This in no way absolves them from responsibility but DOJ pragmatism towards corporations is they way it goes, for now.
If AWS (for example) experienced some significant breach, would the DOJ and/or the public want them punished out of existence? Execs go to jail vs. large corporate fine? Should punitive damages go towards patching the breach or refunding customers? It's a delicate balance and I'm personally undecided on how to scope the fix, even after reading Chickenshit Club.
If AWS maliciously screwed people over in a blatant way and was only 3% of the market, there's a lot less incentive to let them keep on keeping on than if they're 50% of the market.
I think a lot of ills of the current system could be avoided if you had tax penalties or such that scaled aggressively with company size and revenue. Intentionally give up some economies of scale in exchange for flexibility, competitive pressures, and resiliency.
If the services in question are so essential that the government doesn't want it to shut down, then the government should take it over like they did with Freddie and Fannie
2018 USA: If we don't like the executive, we shouldn't get rid of foocorp - think of the impacts to the wider society!
systemic/structural answers to specific problems are rarely the solution, but they sure do help you avoid the cost of dealing with the specific problem..
I hate that attitude so much.
I think you need to source that backlash. I find it highly likely certain people/groups used their media contacts to push that narrative, but I don't know a single actual person besides some Wall Street types who disagreed with the Andersen prosecution... then to extraplote that to "country have trained the government not to." I think is a mistake.
The DOJ problems are not from the public.. they are lack of internal willpower, among other things. They should be doing their job regardless.
It would be wildly unpopular amongst legal scholars, and would itself somewhat threaten the republic.
Nonetheless, as a first order of business, I'd recommend retro-actively eliminating some of the statutes of limitation covering our last few crises.
Then, investigating with full transparency and hanging them out to dry.
And if, really, we can't lift those statutes of limitation, nonetheless forcing such full transparency through aggressive investigation -- and writing laws to support same and hanging those who obstruct in any way, out to dry.
I'm not for micro-managing society through legal action. But, we've selectively enforced basic laws, creating different classes based upon effective legal exposure and risk.
Fundamentally, we've stopped -- to the extent we ever were -- being a society and governance of laws.
I'm more concerned about other economic and power matters, but right now the U.S. is all het up over "immigration". The missing piece in the whole conversation, or particularly "legal enforcement"? Demand. For decades, effectively nothing has been done to those employers who engage in illegal employment.
Which include, by the way, Herr Trump, using and apparently abusing undocumented workers e.g. in his NY construction affairs.
This country, the U.S., is getting to the point of needing a South African type intervention. A truth commission. Because while parts of society feel whole and privileged, it's come with devastating consequences for those who are, after all, supposed to be their fellow citizens.
Just like Puerto Ricans are.
And since we're nowhere near flushing the chickenshits out of government, we have to do the investigation and truth-telling ourselves. And try to bullwark the last bastions for same: The free press and a free Internet.
And in that regard, it seems the race is on.
https://www.schatz.senate.gov/press-releases/schatz-leads-gr...
There's an argument to be made that the Democrats (who I'm a stalwart supporter of) have happily polarized this issue, rather than doing something more quiet while collecting bipartisan support. That what they're doing looks helpful but really isn't.
I find it amusing that the polling that has failed for multiple years is being seen as valid this time around.
I'm a market constructivist, and I'd prefer the simplest possible solution which regulates Equifax and its immense externalities out of existence.
But isn't there also a libertarian case to be made that the credit authorities are a cartel and should be deregulated out of existence? And if that's the case, can't at least some of us find common ground?
I'm not clear on how deregulation would hurt Equifax and the other reporting agencies? It seems that enforcing regulations would hurt them in this case.
Congress represents constituents, it does not protect them. If constituents do not demand action here congress will not pursue further action.
The CFPB is supposed to be protecting consumers, not congress.
1. Change privacy laws so that consumers own their own data. (Something like Germany's BDSG?)
2. Repeal the Fair Credit Reporting Act.
The idea is that once consumers have the weapons and wherewithal to sue irresponsible credit rating authorities out of existence, perhaps fewer "regulations" will be needed.
By default, incumbents and big players have the advantage in the market, so without regulation I doubt anyone could unseat the Big Three agencies. They can afford to have a some inaccuracies and even a breach here and there and still be hard to beat. Remember the people whose data they lost are not their customers. Using the government to force companies to protect that data could level the playing field and increase competition.
As for 1. that is of course regulation.
I'm not so sure it's the Equifax situation here, but rather the CFPB that's the target of partisan lashings. The CFPB has been criticized by both the left and right at various times for overspending, lack of oversight, lack of results, and especially it's fundamental structure - in fact it was even ruled unconstitutional by a DC circuit court. The ruling has since been upheld in an en-banc hearing.
Some of the comments from the judge in the initial ruling are rather surprising:
"The Director enjoys significantly more unilateral power than any single member of any other independent agency. By “unilateral power,” we mean power that is not checked by the President or by other colleagues. Indeed, other than the President, the Director of the CFPB is the single most powerful official in the entire United States Government, at least when measured in terms of unilateral power."
[1]https://www.theatlantic.com/business/archive/2016/10/court-r...
[2]https://www.cadc.uscourts.gov/internet/opinions.nsf/B7623651...
I swore an oath to the constitution, not to a fucking party, so stop trying to tell me your tribe is better, it isn't, and fuck off with the bullshit claims of "but false equivalence"!
The people downvoting you just don't that like you flipped the exact statement of the gp. You are both right.
For instance, it's my understanding that laws exist which protect the big three credit authorities. What are those laws, and what the prospects for changing them?
However, would whatever replaces the big three exhibit the same negative externalities and recreate the same situation of market failure?
I still feel like your analogy doesn't adequately capture the negative externality in the identity theft that the CRAs enable. In a healthy marketplace, the cost of that identity theft would be borne by the people who profit from it, not innocent third parties.
How do we get to a marketplace where that crushing cost falls upon the deserving party, dissuading them from their destructive course? We need to acknowledge that the quantitative change in the accessibility of personal credit information amounts to a qualitative change, justifying a rethink about who owns it.
No, you understood correctly the first time.
https://www.forbes.com/sites/norbertmichel/2017/01/24/the-cf...