That doesn't follow at all. I think you're confusing "contractor vs. employee" with "full-time vs. part-time". Plenty of retail employees are deployed as-needed, and none of them are contractors.
None of those retail employers can clock in and out as they please. "as-needed" is the wrong phrase for sure because it indicates the choice is in the hand of the employer. "as-desired" would be better.
It's a weighting of factors argument, right? It's probably not simple (or these cases would all be finished by now). Counting against the contractor definition: single, longstanding continuous relationship.
But most of the driving-giggers that I know do not have single relationships, they're working with both Uber and Lyft, or GrubHub, Seamless, Doordash, etc, as each one rises and falls in profitability for them.