Mixed-use developments may actually reduce housing affordability
phys.org
phys.org
Feels like clickbait and a statement of the obvious - of course well thought out and walkable developments will attract a premium when compared to less walkable and useful developments. If we want people to not be priced out, we need to build enough to meet the demand and redevelop existing stock to match the current trends.
And you know what, we’ll still be rebuilding neighborhoods to match the then current trends 100 years from now. That’s the entire point - if the city doesn’t adapt to what people need/want overtime, areas that reflect those preferences will become unaffordable, whereas areas that do not reflect those preferences will decrease in value.
The answer is to do this more, until it's not special, and during the process subsidize. In fact, if mixed-use areas are inherently more livable, build more public housing projects around a mixed-use format.
> The study of Toronto neighbourhoods found that the increased cost, which was further heightened by the retraction of government support for affordable housing in mixed-use areas[...]
If we want more affordable living spaces, we need to build build build.
Most affordable housing activists either don't understand or outright disbelieve that such filtering is possible. They're also somewhat impatient, so they want to see brand new yet affordable housing get built.
Unfortunately, because urban housing was uncool for decades virtually all urban housing tends to be either very old and run-down, recently remodeled and expensive, or recently built and expensive. There are no decent-yet-affordable 20-30 year old downtown apartments/condos.
Since we find affordable housing through (effective) taxes on market rate construction, blocking it yields lower total affordable housing production.
But in some cities, like New York and San Francisco, many of the new luxury apartments are being bought up by foreign investors who keep the apartment empty, or being bought up by rich outsiders who are moving into the city for the first time. So the increase in housing supply at the upper end of the market is only inducing additional demand and keeping prices high, instead of working against existing demand and either lowering prices or improving value (i.e. sticky prices which stay high, but buyers can now get a nicer apartment for the same cost).
Such "filtering" is definitely possible, but you'd have to find out a way to restrict immigration and market speculation to make it a reality.
People move to New York and San Francisco because they get jobs there, not because apartments are built.
[1]https://www.sfgate.com/news/article/Geneva-Towers-To-Tumble-...
I was a teenager in 1992 in a part of Chicago getting gentrified, and I recall socialist activists literally telling kids not to pick up litter for this reason.
They had a point...
It's plainly obvious that an increase in the supply of available housing increases affordability of housing and a decrease similarly decreases it. And similarly with demand.
Not everything has it's price determined by the blunt cudgel of supply and demand but things that are needed to live clearly do.
More housing means more people, but prices might even go up.
Either way, when you legalize housing and build more houses, you end up with more houses. That makes getting a house easier, for someone, somewhere.
Indeed. Contrast New York City and Buffalo.
The amount of liquidity has little to do with the overall supply-demand balance. There is plenty of AMZN stock available for purchase; doesn't make it cheap.
Many find this unpalatable, as it extends access from the upper middle class and then down instead of from the homeless and then up. Favored alternatives (rent control, affordability requirements) don’t meaningfully increase access at all, but merely redistribute it from highest bidders to lottery/waiting list winners.