At Google's size, there are extra accounting processes that you should follow.
You might be looking at Google like a single giant thing while in fact it's a complex arrangement of companies and departments underneath.
At Google's size, there are extra accounting processes that you should follow.
You might be looking at Google like a single giant thing while in fact it's a complex arrangement of companies and departments underneath.
I've always assumed when I see an ad for Google Chrome in the sponsored section in Google web search that it is money coming out of Google Chrome's marketing budget. So, it should technically count as revenue for Google web search.
Which is why I think corporate taxes on profit is silly. Taxes should be based on revenue, not on profit. That you choose to reinvest all of your profits back into the company should be immaterial. If a corporation has 1% of its revenue as profit vs another corporation has 25% of revenue as profit is not our problem.
For a global corporation, it may (and likely does, potentially advantaged even) have tax implications -- but from a general profit/loss perspective it's still basically zero sum (though may actually cost them money in lost revenues/inventory in practice, which presumably gets booked as a liability if it's without compensation).
But a guiding principle of taxes is: discouraging unwanted behaviour (or encouraging, through tax cuts / subsidies). We want to encourage corporations to invest, i.e. "putting the money back into the economy". Keep buying those new machines, upgrading your assembly line, upgrading your fleet of cars, for ever increasing efficiency and economic activity.
If you're talking about one company investing buy buying products from itself (like Google is, here), then hopefully the money one branch deducts from its revenue becomes additional profits for the other branch of the same company.
Sure, in theory, practice and theory are equal. In practice, they're not. Tons of loopholes exist around just this aspect of accounting and tax law. But there is at least a theoretical reason to tax profits, over revenue.
This means that every layer in a series of transactions to the customer would add costs. Great for the biggest companies who can do everything in house, terrible for smaller companies acting in a chain.
A massive company who buys raw materials and produces everything in house and sells for £1000 would pay tax on revenue of £1000 per widget.
A series of small companies may have:
Refinery: revenue £100
Part production: revenue £200
Construction: revenue £300
Wholesaler: revenue £400
Brick and mortar store: revenue £500
Now the massive company pays tax on £1000 but this series of companies pays tax on £1500.
And we could call it Value Added Tax!
Net margin varies wildly by industry. That would be hard to implement in a way that wasn't slanted to disproportionately reward high margin industry...further increasing their margins.