Speculation is more zero-sum, but can send useful price signals when tied to an asset that relates to production.
However, speculation that is completely disconnected from production is just gambling... zero-sum. Actually negative-sum, if we include wasted energy and time.
Yes.
> Speculation is more zero-sum, but can send useful price signals when tied to an asset that relates to production.
Yes, with the qualifier that the individual trades are what’s zero sum, with the aggregate activity and emergent signals causing the positive sum in real investment.
> However, speculation that is completely disconnected from production is just gambling... zero-sum.
No. Uninformed speculation is less useful for price discovery than informed speculation, but it does not nullify informed speculation. Furthermore, efficient price discovery is facilitated by liquidity, and uninformed speculation is a net improvement in liquidity.
Furthermore, the incentive may be much higher than is actually required, and creates a lot of collateral waste in the process.
Every bit of time, energy, and resources spent in this speculative endeavor crowds out other activities. And a large amount of this effort is just spent on a cybersecurity arms race over these hypothetically valuable tokens.
I realize you were trying to make a point about speculation in general, such as with futarchy. Any kind of speculation over things related to real production, including bets about CEO performance, would have some obvious informational value. But bets about sports do not.
Picture 500 years of interest vs a small bit of gold. Granted this assumes they buy the gold as an investment but if it's not sold for 500 years that seems reasonable.
Except I am saying it goes to 0 so they don't actually get any gold. So, it's option A get nothing or option B possibly get something of value. I don't see how option A is better.
While the single dimension of buy and sell price for any asset can be negative sum if it depreciates after your purchase, whether or not the complete value of the asset is net positive or net negative is a function of 1) the quantifiable advantages, like (but not necessarily) dividends or risk reduction, and 2) the amount of time spent holding it. This second point is also why the frequency of price changes (and net change in any discrete measure of time) is a very important part of the analysis.
Say I buy 1,000,000$ worth of gold and agree the vault owner can sell gold to cover the costs for the next 100 years. Alternatively, I can spend 1,000,000$ but get less than 1,000,000$ worth of gold to pay for the vault. In either case in 100 years someone needs to keep paying for the vault. Any finite amount of gold is not enough to pay for it's storage costs forever.
PS: You can spend less on security but you risk having nothing of it's stolen. Given enough time and it will be.
You can quantify those costs for the same measures of time that I keep talking about in this thread. As I keep saying: the cost of storing the asset is economically, demonstrably lower than the value of the asset for any meaningful, discrete timespan.
> PS: You can spend less on security but you risk having nothing of it's stolen. Given enough time and it will be.
By this logic, literally everything is negative sum according to thermodynamics. You’re not using a reasonable, accepted definition for this concept in the context of game theory.
We know the heat death of the universe is going to happen, so does that mean the aggregate activity of the market is negative sum? This isn’t just incorrect, it’s incoherent.
Gold sitting in a vault stays gold sitting in a vault the outputs are identical in form and lower in amount.
PS: A bank safety deposit box costs ~60$ a year store 1,000$ worth of gold for 20 years and you lost money unless it's worth more than twice as much inflation adjusted. Store 1,000,000$ worth of gold costs more than 60$ / month, but not 1000x more so it's not as pointless.