If you think that coming up with theorems about, e.g. infinitary algebra, is intuitive, then I guess you're just a lot smarter than I am. Infinities always throw a wrench into our intuitions. Something being a "logical consequence" of something else is an incredibly simplistic way of looking at things, not to mention that I'm not exactly sure what that has to do with intuition anyway.
That 'non-intuitive' aspect of high-dimensional spheres having very small volume relative to a hypercube becomes a point that builds intuition for how those spheres behave, once you're familiar with it. And then you can start throwing out things that seem intuitively wrong, and following intuition towards new ideas.
> the power or faculty of attaining to direct knowledge or cognition without evident rational thought and inference
There is such a thing as developing your intuition.
I think your meanings are not qualitatively different.
The trick is that you need good data to feed it that makes the patterns clear. You might have not gotten a lot of that on the topic you had no intuition of. On some topics, there hasn't been much of an attempt to do that since people expect it to be hard with everyone forced to do the methods that are non-intuitive. Lots of traditions are like that. Then, there's the possibility something can't be intuitively handled at all. I don't know if those exist but they might. That many activities of people doing math seem to get an intuitive boost during their day-to-day work makes me lean towards intuitive possibilities for about everything that can be approximated (esp with heuristics).
Let's claim that writing a proof is similar to writing a program. You start from a state, your premise, and have your assumptions, input, which you process through a series of steps, maybe taking cases in between (branching) and return an output (hopefully True).
Then considering this correspondence, it will be fine to say that you, as a programmer, can guess the output/behavior/semantics of any program without running it. Similarly, a mathematician would be able to reach the conclusion that the theorem holds, without going through all the details of the proof.
Sure, in most cases you can, and as you get more and more experience and knowledge as a programmer you can say you improve your guesses. But this ends up backfiring with a good probability, when our model skipped a step, e.g. the interaction of two concurrent data structures.
Thus I don't think it is right to say "as you are able to know all axioms and rules of inference, you should be able to achieve perfect intuition". You can know the fundamentals of each layer on your stack and you would find it insane if one asked you to guess the output of any non-trivial terminating program.
Note also that the way of inference (logical consequences) can and does change (e.g. ZF vs ZFC).
() I may be misusing the word model here -- it is usually defined (at least to things I work with) as the interpretation of a theory that satisfies all theorems (inferences). () constructive proofs yes. No flame wars please :)
But respectfully, ZFC came about because of logical paradoxes that couldn't be accepted as consistent.
You can create a new number system and derive all kinds of consequences but the truth is, most mathematicians care more entirely about prime number theory on the naturals that are entirely based on counting.
Most of modern math is based on the natural numbers. You can't remove all intuition. The thread that holds our love for math is also the same one that tells us we are exploring consequences that tell us a dearth about our universe.