[Edit:] Oh, I see. In the SV land driving a company into the ground is a win!
[Edit:] Oh, I see. In the SV land driving a company into the ground is a win!
Same for the argument that there was a ton of learnings when Pebble failed. Yes, maybe but how is that relevant to other startups? Even for the hardware space, if someone seemingly never managed to get the production pipeline going and never had a vision for the products, how much worth is the advice then? Failing fast and often is not applicable here. Heck, I got a more or less failed startup, I probably can tell you some stuff but definitely not, how everything works or how to be successful.
SV is a strange place. It feels, it's more important how much money you have (raised) then how successful your company was/is.
The premise is the same: he lost so he can teach quite a few lessons that he learned while losing.
How about this? Would you hire a football player that made it to the national team but performed horrible (and was fired by the manager) on that stage as a coach for your team - the one with the aspiration for Champions league?
How about a doctor? Would you go to the one whose patients died vs. the one whose have not?
Why is it different for VC partners?
A dude who had to take a hardware company through all the shit required from the bottom up into a time where now people can finally actually start doing hardware companies is going to know so much about how to help companies in ALL regards, dude was one of the most successful trailblazers, even if the trail died out. Hardware is fucking hard from every aspect and he knows about every aspect, that's why people will want his help.
Someone investing into US treasury would have made more money than they made giving him money. That's the only objective way that we currently have to establish a success or a failure of a company executive and his or her knowledge and smarts.