> I'm not sure regulation is to blame for megacorp monopolies. When you have so much money that you can bury any competition, and buy up all the regulators, regulation is effectively useless.
It's not just useless, it's actively harmful. The regulations are created at the behest of the megacorp to harm prospective competitors.
The problem is we can sit here and agree that we need better regulations, and call Congress and tell them to pass better regulations, and then a 5000 page bill comes up for a vote. Normal people don't have time to understand what's in it, but megacorp's lawyers do. So if it's something they like it sails right through and if it's something they hate they pay for a truckload of sand to be poured into the gears so it never goes anywhere.
So the alternatives are A) "have megacorp's preferred regulations" or B) "stop federally regulating that thing" and there is no third option on the table. Which do you choose?
"Get a third option" would be great, if anybody knew how to actually do that. But every time anybody has claimed they're going to do it in the last century or so we just end up with option A instead.
It'd be great if we still had Teddy Roosevelt in there, but we don't, and he's not even on the ballot.
> It seems having too much money/power is the real problem. Regulation can only stop bad behavior if regulators have more power than the regulated. That can lead to a stagnation of innovation though.
Fixing this tends to have counterintuitive solutions.
People are always talking about "the 1%" as if the problem is people, but the main problem is really corporations. There is no natural person with more money than Apple Inc.
And the biggest reason for that is that we have a tax system that rewards huge multinational corporations hoarding cash. The only reason the shareholders don't demand their take of the profits is that they know that actually taking them causes a large amount of taxes to be due to both the company and the shareholder. So they take their gains as share price appreciation, which has preferential tax treatment but leaves the huge pile of money inside the corporation.
There are two main things needed to fix that. The first is to replace corporate income tax with VAT, so there is no more incentive for corporations to hold money offshore. And the second is to defer taxes when dividends or capital gains are immediately reinvested, so that an investor who takes profits from a megacorp and invests them in a small or medium business doesn't immediately owe a bunch of taxes, when leaving the cash in the megacorp wouldn't.
The problem is both of these policies will inevitably get characterized as helping the rich, even though their effect is to eliminate the relative costs of moving profits from megacorps to smaller businesses.