A specific medical claim will trigger FDA requirements to prove efficacy in the US. Thats why you see lots of products not making claims, for instance — “High in antioxidants!”, some people will interpret that to mean improved health outcomes, but the manufacturer is not claiming it.
Part of me wants to try to market some strong reducing agents as "high in antioxidants". Like carbon monoxide air fresheners, cyanide candy, hydrazine sport drinks, etc.