Strong AI is not hard to reason about because it is science fiction. As edanm pointed out, it is entirely possible to reason about science fiction. The difference is that the examples edanm points out are extensions or modifications of things that do exist and that provides a basis from which we can reasonably extrapolate.
We can't reason about strong AI precisely because we don't have as good of an existing example from which we can extrapolate. The best we have is the human mind. The extrapolation from the human mind is precisely the basis for argument that "friendly strong AI" is the best/only response to to "malicious strong AI" since the thing that keeps malicious humans in check is "good" humans.
We don't even know if or to what degree 'super-intelligence' is possible. For all we know, there may be fundamental trade offs between the different skills necessary for general intelligence that may provide functional limits to the degree to which intelligence can be super human.