But also, centralized light systems are not new. Many corporate facilities have been using these for years and they rarely fail.
Maybe the problem is that your father just picked the wrong vendor/system.
But also, centralized light systems are not new. Many corporate facilities have been using these for years and they rarely fail.
Maybe the problem is that your father just picked the wrong vendor/system.
If the hub died, the smart bulbs can still still be operated using the regular light switch. If the bulb is in standby (smart "off") just flip the switch twice to turn it on. Then it will act like a regular bulb until the hub returns.
Hue only has one big defect with regards to this... If there's an electrical outage and the smart bulb is in standby, when power is restored the bulb will turn on. Meaning if power goes out and is restored in the middle of the night the lights could suddenly turn on full brightness.
And as an aside, the nice thing about smartbulbs as a concept is that they require zero re-wiring or specialized wiring. So if the manufacturer of your bulbs went out of business or you wanted to change vendors, just replace the bulb and your work is done. Simple.
One thing I really like about "smart" things, when the power is out at home I can check my phone to see if power is restored. I guess that's similar to calling your home to see if the answering machine is back on.
(I still love them and am happy I have them rather than regular LEDs though.)
But surely the controller iwll sort this out when it gets back online a minute later?
So that everything comes on (annoying enough) but switched off within the minute?
If not that is just outrageously bad and imo ruins the product completely.
It's pretty common occurrence in many locales where I've lived.
We had a power flicker last week in the middle of the night and suddenly our bedroom lights were on 100% and our Echo was loudly complaining that the internet was gone. At 3am.
For smart lights you need "Return to previous state, and then see if the state was on a timer. If it was, wait until you get an NTP answer (i.e. the Internet isn't down) and set up the state requested by the timer."
Which is fine unless the previous state was a party, it's now daylight, and all the bulbs are still different colours.
Or someone was adjusting the lights and accidentally set them to 1% instead of 100% when the power went off.
Everything becomes an edge case. The most useful solution requires an intelligent default with timer support, with some awareness of what's happening in and around the house.
And it still has to allow for user overrides, because some people - like my partner - sometimes want the lights on during the day, even when the room is bright.
I also have analog switches and dimmers in my house. If I have the lights at the lowest setting when the power goes out, that's where they are when the power returns. If everything was on full when the power goes out, then that's where things will be when the power returns.
Why should smart things work differently than what a lifetime of experience has lead me to expect?
And lights coming back on at full intensity after a power outage? Pretty common in analog houses as well. Who thinks to turn off a light that isn't on?
You could go the whole hog and install enough UPS for the whole house and a backup generator.
I guess the reason you have to flip the switch twice, is to prevent this problem. Then, if you get an outage during the night, it should continue to be off...
(Just like we have to do every 30 mins in the office when there's 3 or fewer in.)
That's the same with regular bulbs, so...
1. As good as they have gotten, they still aren’t nearly as instantaneous as a good old fashioned switch. Yes, there are ways to mitigate this, from having it decide when to turn on to alternative controls. But that latency really gets to me sometimes.
2. The system not recalling last state. If you are worried about not being able to default to lights being on, you can make it so that a quick toggle resets it. But I can be convinced of other options/opinions here.
In general, I think the import point is how smart/dumb an object it is. It is more important how “rock solid” it is, and simple to use. I love the mantra “don’t make me think”. Devices should become “invisible” for the task you care about.
I'm sorry but this is unacceptable. It's what keeps me from adopting Hue in my own home.
My lighting system literally has one job, if an advancement of this technology can't keep analog reliability, I don't want it (That's a bug, not a feature).
Don't get me wrong, I love the idea of Hue, color changing bulbs, ability to remote control, ability to dim, etc. is awesome, but maybe should stay in a switch format if loss of power can't be handled correctly.
Since the only UI is "hold the switch down for longer or shorter periods, or press it repeatedly", and there are no written instructions and no discoverability, nobody can reliably work it and we routinely hold meetings in the dim half-light.
It's like living in Clamp Tower from Gremlins II.
That way, you wouldn't have to shut down the entire system.
Adding a switch changes the assembly process, requires extra firmware and testing, makes manufacture more complicated, demands localised labelling (unless you can work out a symbol system which maybe 50% of users won't get), and requires changes to the manual.
That way, it would be more clear to the customer why the product with the physical stops and manual overrides is more expensive.