Did Linus also criticize the complexity and untested nature of systemd?
Did Linus also criticize the complexity and untested nature of systemd?
(IIRC, they claimed it offered better performance, Linus ran some benchmarks and claimed the kernel-dbus implementation performed worse than the regular dbus daemon. My memory on the subject is fairly vague, though, so don't take my word on it.)
Keep in mind that at one point he was so fed up with Kay Sievers that he announced he would not accept any kernel patches that originated from that person.
I think it related to Sievers unilaterally deciding that the kernel, and not udev, should be responsible for loading firmwares, leading to the kernel devs scrambling to implement the required functionality. In the aftermath some kernel devs even pondered forking udev and bundling it with the kernel code as part of its userspace toolkit.
And this was from before udev was merged with systemd (iirc).
I suppose it could also be argued that the kernel is also unnecessarily complex as well?
I would like to offer, as a counter example, every micro kernel ever.
The closest relative is NT and that is a hybrid, not purely micro. Modular and hybrid kernels (Linux and NT respectively) offer better external vs internal complexity tradeoffs; Linux and NT are internally complex since they do all the hard stuff, micorkernels are externally complex since someone else needs to do the hard work.
Microkernels will shove this exact complexity elsewhere not make it go away.