https://fightthefuture.org/article/the-new-era-of-corporate-...
..and the CTO who made that decision later backed down and said he wouldn't make that same decision again. O_o
I really feel like the biggest reason they're still in business is that very few alternatives offer anything really competitive.
The fact that American TV networks weren't allowed to say "shithole" in reporting what the US President said is an example of censorship. The FCC, a government agency, requires that they not use certain words. When Fox decided to get rid of O'Reilly that's not censorship that's just basic ability to read how the wind is blowing.
Private censorship is still censorship, however. It is also a form of speech itself.
There are like ten thousand other options...
Also, they were amongst the only ones to offer ECDSA certificates IIRC.
Cloudflare detailed a little bit about this in this and other blog posts:
Having multiple issuers is important for us as each CA, at some point in time, has operational issues. Additionally, as you've seen with Symantec, browsers take action to distrust certain issuers/roots.
When either of these scenarios happens, our customers don't care if it's the third-party that's down—they expect fast and reliable issuance from us (Cloudflare).
What Cloudflare does is dangerous to the integrity of safe browsing, for a variety of reasons. And their aggressive marketing to convince a lot of tech-ignorant people with low traffic websites that they need a CDN is harmful.
Is it too much to ask that their service at least operate in a way that doesn't poison the internet they're getting rich from?
Did your colleague mis-speak?
The main issue is that Cloudflare needs to have plain-text traffic to examine, which cannot be done with End-to-End encryption from the client to the origin server, in which case you would definitely need a separate certificate for each domain.
I'm simply pointing out that when you have incompetent and crooked people in tech, they often run in packs.
You might argue that altruism has no place in business but I disagree. When the CEO of Comodo launched his attack on Let's Encrypt, Cloudflare had opportunity to cut all ties with them. There's plenty of other CAs they could work with. They chose to ignore that scandal, and that matters.