However, that is apparently a deal breaker, which makes me suspicious because many organizations have no trouble implementing Let's Encrypt SSL despite the lack of wildcard support. That + Past Behavior = suspicion.
Which part is a deal breaker? I'm not sure what you are getting at.
I am quoting an earlier comment in this very thread: "We use several CAs to issue—Comodo, DigiCert, GlobalSign—and will be adding Let's Encrypt once they support i) SHA-2/ECDSA signatures and ii) wildcards."