1. "rounding modes and overflow behavior are not addressed", which is incorrect.
2. "Where's exp(), log(), sin(), cos()?", which you can find in dec64_math.c.
3. "There are also 255 representations of almost all representable numbers", which is incorrect.
4. "it will take around FIFTY INSTRUCTIONS TO CHECK IF TWO NUMBERS ARE EQUAL OR NOT" in the slow case, which is probably true but is unlikely to be common given the design of the type. It can undoubtedly be improved with effort.
5. "The exponent bits should be the higher order bits. Otherwise, this type breaks compatibility with existing comparator circuitry", which seems like an odd comment given the type is not normalized.
6. "With both fields being 2's compliment, you're wasting a bit, just to indicate sign", which AFAICT is just false.
7. "there's no fraction support", which I don't understand.
So the only valid criticism I saw in that whole thread is #4, and even that is only a tenth as valid as its author thought it was.