I suppose it's a question of your threat model. Do you trust the website to not do that? Given that FBI is willing to take over and continue operating websites that distribute child porn, the default answer to that question ought to be no. You have no way of knowing if someone else has taken a server over.
Maybe a browser extension would be a good way to do PGP encryption for websites, keeping the key out of their reach but allowing a one-click encryption right in the browser.