The result is an inefficient system that incentivizes inequality and lowers productivity, protecting the interests of the insiders in detriment to society.
And, from what I hear from Italian friends, they are usually linked to the local mafia group.
The result is an inefficient system that incentivizes inequality and lowers productivity, protecting the interests of the insiders in detriment to society.
And, from what I hear from Italian friends, they are usually linked to the local mafia group.
Furthermore, in a corporate structure, those at the bottom of the rung have absolutely zero say in what upper management does.
No, coops here survive because of government protection against competition.
> The real key factor here is that coops at least open up the possibility of workers sharing in the profits generated by their labor.
No, they don't. A coop can be of owners, as it is frequently the case in Italy. A coop of small farms, each employing a dozen people, doesn't necessarily bring any benefit to those employees, only to the owners.
And it leaves them vulnerable to competition from outside, which then require even more government protection, hindering trade and economic development.
Coops aren't any different.
Though some of the Italian statistics were ambiguous as to whether they included non-worker-owned coops (perhaps even deceptively so!), the main thrust of the article was clearly about worker-owned coops
While cooperatives in the United States claim about 130
million memberships, these are by and large within consumer
and producer-owned co-ops, not cooperative workplaces. Only
around 7,000 people nationwide are part of worker co-ops.Your talking a producer coop which a lot of the US ones are including one that supplies KFC.
That's incorrect. The Capitalist structure enables multiple avenues of labor competition, one of which is to pay more than the next company to get the workers you need, and to pay workers more, ie take better care of them, to keep them happy. These approaches are extraordinarily common.
That so many businesses offer health insurance benefits - such that half of all Americans get their health insurance from their employer - wasn't always a legal requirement (and in many cases still isn't). That happened out of labor competition. It's no different than numerous other competitive benefits that companies choose to offer.
Google, Microsoft, Netflix, et al. often pay programmers extraordinary salaries to attract the best. The competition between companies has driven salaries to the moon. See: AI talent.
The SAS Institute, as one example model, has been doing profit sharing for four decades, and it has proven to be a wildly successful Capitalist approach.
Walmart has used the over-paying approach for decades. By intentionally paying more than they absolutely have to based on state / federal minimum wage requirements, to lure labor away from smaller businesses that can't match what Walmart can pay. Walmart has had a voracious appetite for labor over the last 30 years, the sole means to keep 2.x million people on the payrolls, is to out-compete on pay.
Speaking from experience of having seen it up close across multiple decades, if the federal minimum wage is $7.25 and you pay even just $9.25 or $10.50 instead, you will attract considerably superior employees versus if you pay the minimum. And the quality gap between those two types of employee, is surprisingly vast. Even if you're running a very thin margin business with minimum ability to pay high wages, a convenience store for example, paying a few dollars more per hour is well worth it because it produces a big leap in the quality of employees you can hire.
I find it a rather sad state of affairs that you need private health insurance in the first place.
While I agree with you that competition for some skills that are in high demand tends to push wages up significantly for those who are lucky enough to possess such skills, for majority of jobs where there is ample supply of workers, companies certainly favour distributing profits to management, dividends and financial engineering like share buybacks rather than spending it on the workers.
In an employee owned organisation you would assume the worker/owners would get higher compensation, but it seems like their governance is also often corrupted and in reality they can be worse places to work at.
It is interesting to see if governance models using technology (like blockchain based equity and voting, like http://aragon.one) for organisations prove to be more resistant to corruption and can usher new ways of organising ownership and work.
You might be confusing it with laissez faire, which isn't necessarily a free market.
https://www.kff.org/private-insurance/issue-brief/trends-in-employer-sponsored-insurance-offer-and-coverage-rates-1999-2014/
Healthcare coverage became popular because of unions and because of government tax policy combined with government regulations that require employers to offer workers the same healthcare plans as management (if provided at all). Moreover, the overall insured rate also declined over that time period. https://aspe.hhs.gov/basic-report/overview-uninsured-united-states-summary-2011-current-population-survey
What really changed between 1999 and 2014 was the continued decline of unions concomitant with accelerated overseas out-sourcing and a shift to part-time labor (where government regulations regarding benefit equity permits greater discrimination against employees).Make of that what you will (the implications are complex), but realize that in terms of labor market dynamics and relative to what's theoretically economically optimal, the predominance of employer-sponsored healthcare is a very... odd... outcome, and hardly an exemplar of the benefits of free market enterprise. In as much as it was beneficial it required external, non-market[1] pressures, and in any event it's hardly praiseworthy.
[1] I'll assume for the sake of argument that government-enforced union arbitration is more market antagonistic than the government-enforced limited liability of corporate stockholders. But in my view I don't see how the laws which make it viable for unions to bargain collectively in the labor market are worse than laws which make capitalist financing viable.
I thought it happened out of a tax break and things never went back to normal.
https://www.peoplekeep.com/blog/part-1-the-history-of-u.s.-e...
Um... no? The point of a coop is to make money, just like a joint-stack corporation. In fact, a co-op is a joint stock corporation where the owners are also workers.
> They are (usually government-sanctioned or government-protected) producer organizations
Coops have no government protection, at least no more than mega corporations. Recall that it was GM who was determined to be 'too big to fail', not Mondragon.
Protection comes in many forms, such as special tax structures, protected denominations and excessive regulation.
In America, it is routine for large companies to negotiate tax deals with local governments. Many American companies pay no local tax at all. Local authorities do this as a 'gift' to make companies stay. It's wrong everywhere, but it has nothing to do with co-ops.
None of the above sound bad in themselves.
In many areas we could do with less competition, more tariffs, and more cultural protection and subsidies.
Actually, all of them are bad in themselves. Government-granted monopolies reduce innovation and consumer surplus, inhibit competition and stagnate an economy, leaving it weak and unable to compete internationally.
> In many areas we could do with less competition, more tariffs, and more cultural protection and subsidies.
No, we could not.
The question isn't which abstract model is better, the question is how we build some sort of conventions that work better than what is happening now.
Oh, sure, there's potential for improvement. But so far there hasn't been a model that works better, and every single time that government-protected monopolies were tried, they failed with disastrous results.
Every single new model tried has failed miserably.
But that also doesn't mean there aren't ways to improve the current model.
This has no basis on the real world. Many of the largest companies in the world are subsidized by the government, including in the US. For example, Boeing/Airbus is a de-facto duopoly, subsidized by taxpayers. The biggest problems of these companies is that they are owned by private individuals. Having them formed as coops solves a major issue. While not perfect, I don't see these coops as any worse than other companies.
And it has plenty of evidence in the real world, just look at AT&T, cable companies, ISPs, mail carriers, etc.
And look at monopoly pricing.
> The biggest problems of these companies is that they are owned by private individuals. Having them formed as coops solves a major issue.
No, it doesn't. Coops are also owned by shareholders, and with government protection, they are monopolies, extracting economic rents from consumers. And economic rents are always, always bad.
Where is your pension/ 401k invested pray?
Only if one believes in the free market ideology and have no other measure of what's valuable than monetary.
And even then, it's a stretch. All the big economies (the US first and foremost) grew to what they are by using tons of subsidies, tariffs and so on. And even now they use non-economic advantages (diplomatic and military pressure for one) to maintain their status.