I worry you may be asking for a bit much in a thread discussing austerity and the rise of Nazism.
I worry you may be asking for a bit much in a thread discussing austerity and the rise of Nazism.
It is high quality... For another site.
From the guidelines of what off topic: "Most stories about politics". If this is allowed, the guidelines don't mean much.
Emphasis mine.
Like i said, if this fits under that restriction then almost anything fits. You might just as well remove that line and start allowing all politics since that what it is in practice.
From my perspective the mix of stories here hasn't changed much in 10 years.
The site guidelines say most and probably for a reason. This article obviously clears that bar. The vast majority of political stories don't, so what you say downthread is far from true.
You might hope that a story like this is one we can all find intellectually interesting and discuss without falling into a political vortex. But it's a political topic that reacts with almost every other political issue on HN, from US politics to Greece and the EU.
I think he's right and you're wrong, for whatever that's worth.
I'm not sure your point is borne out by the thread. Most comments are civil and substantive. It isn't the highest quality discussion but graded on a curve it's good.
My inclination was to penalize the article because of the triggery title. But I took a look and had to change my mind. The article is substantive and gratifies intellectual curiosity; that's the site mandate (https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html), so I'd say it's clearly germane.
The topic itself is troll city, of course, which is why I posted the sticky comment at the top. We have to judge this by the article, not overall topic. Even if nearly everything on a topic is crap or flamebait, occasionally something isn't, and it's important to how HN works to treat those exceptions differently—even though having blanket rules would be easier, and a lot of people mistakenly think we do have them.