It would be used by 1% of the population, with the other 99% using something else that looks much like what we have today.
I was going to say something like this, except without the assumption that what we have today would exist. For all the concerns about walled gardens, I can still link to a Facebook post in a Slack message and vice versa. The hypothetical non-web-world would probably consist of Compuservs and MSNs, with very limited notions of links.
You pretty much described Facebook's "internet".org / "free basics" in your last sentence.
Can you link directly to a Facebook video? That has gotten extremely hard unless you are using their app for some reason.
The timestamp is usually a direct link, I've used it to share a video a few times.
You have a lot of faith in our current system
I wouldn't say so. I'm distraught by it, actually.
Since Richard Stallman was around when sir Tim Berners-Lee developed the web, I guess we found out.