YouTube Limits Mods to Viewing 4 Hours of Disturbing Content per Day
theverge.com
theverge.com
EDIT: Here are two articles:
https://www.wired.com/2014/10/content-moderation/
http://www.nytimes.com/2010/07/19/technology/19screen.html
The first link has a good comment on why this is a big deal: "If someone was uploading animal abuse, a lot of the time it was the person who did it. He was proud of that," Rob says. "And seeing it from the eyes of someone who was proud to do the fucked-up thing, rather than news reporting on the fucked-up thing—it just hurts you so much harder, for some reason. It just gives you a much darker view of humanity."
But the universe doesn't care about our intuitions.
The example that immediately comes to mind for me is railway lookout. Sometimes for practical reasons rather than closing a railway to send people onto the track, or deploying technological countermeasures to protect the workers, we have to resort to a human stood at a vantage point looking out for trains and signalling to their co-workers on the track. In principle this should happen only when it's absolutely necessary, in practice humans, even those who actually work on the track, often think it sounds _easier_ and pick it over safer alternatives.
Humans are really bad at being lookout because it's very boring. You stare into the distance, and Either a thing happens, or it doesn't, for minute after minute. With practice, and in the knowledge that if you screw-up your co-workers (probably friends) may die or be gruesomely injured by a train, workers can remain focused on this very boring task for almost an hour in test conditions.
But try telling a team of hard-working manual labourers that an hour as lookout, then a proper break for a couple of hours and then one more session of an hour as lookout constitutes a working day. They can agree intellectually that this is so, having done the job, but stood there, not breaking a sweat, just kind of bored, if one of them is mistakenly not relieved they will try to grit their teeth and carry on. And then, perhaps, the boredom overwhelms them, and before they know it a colleague is lying broken in a ditch, there are blue lights, people crying, investigators are asking them questions about what they saw, what they remember...
She had a promising career right out of college and was excited to be working at Google, even though it wasn't what she wanted to be doing. After about a month she would just start crying randomly on nights and weekends when we hung out.
After about a year she quit to become a baker. I really think she has a kind of PTSD from it.
If there was one job I wish the robots could take, its this one. Although its important that it be a super highly qualified AI, and not the crap we have now.
This is probably not actually a good idea... moderation takes training and making everyone do it could make it harder to recruit and retain talented engineers. The attractiveness of the idea is probably more attributable to how frustrating the problem is.
Not do more harm by collecting the worst of the worst and forcing everyone in a room to watch it....
I worked for a search engine / media company early in my career. Big enough that if I said the name you might remember their TV ads from the 90s. But when I worked there it was after the dot-com bubble and the content moderation team was down to one guy in a room with the door shut so know one else could see his screen.
So on top of looking at disturbing content all day he was isolated from other humans. And it's not like he could discuss his job with them. It's not really "polite conversation."
I wouldn't wish that job on anyone.
This disturbing Youtube video problem is an interesting one, it feels like a persistent DoS attack on the platform.
They already promised to hire 10k people.
If you only have to pay each for 4 hours rather than 8 per day, you pay less.
The 2x speed viewing is handy for things like subtitled recipes and I’d imagine would be used for something like this as well.