AFAICT, neither of them have designed anything. Elon Musk has an executive role. Carmack's role is unclear. Happy to go through any information you've come across..
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Virtual_reality#History
This will no doubt boil down to some warped definition of what the term "modern" means.
>Elon Musk, who studied aerospace on his own, is building rockets. John Carmack, who holds no degree at all, has done the same on a smaller scale.
Have you read Masters of Doom or even Googled the question?
Edit: Please don't take this as a diss on his work. Just because one didn't play a role in designing the rockets, doesn't mean they were not crucial to the project.