City Passes the First Bitcoin Mining Ban in the US
motherboard.vice.com
motherboard.vice.com
On a side note, the city's goal was to use cheap electricity to lure industry to town, and their policy did exactly what they tried to. Seems like they didn't exactly plan out what would happen if they succeeded.
Instead of selling th energy for a pretty penny to the NE USA, they sell it below-market to preserve a small number of jobs in the industry since it’s highly automated.
$300 000 to preserve each job per year https://www.iedm.org/3341--300-000-per-job-each-year-for-35-...
In a way. Obviously their goal was growth: to attract industry whose wages and hopefully some profits would go back into the local economy. That's not going to happen with Bitcoin mining. If 200 local jobs had been created, then the story would be different.
But there's also a second issue: even if the bitcoin operation had brought jobs, it still used enough power to raise everyone's electric bills by $100-200 a month. That's huge, and it's not obvious that it's even worth it.
Of course, you can argue that if a business had high labor costs, it never would have expanded as much as or as quickly as the bitcoin mining businesses did.
Manuel Davis O'Kelley The Moon is a Harsh Mistress
When they harm others, then yes.
It's the same reason why we ban theft, murder, etc.
Do not presume to dictate what others do. If there really are negative externalities set regulation to price those externalities in. At worst create step functions in pricing to discourage behaviors above some typical threshold. But outright banning something that others find utility in just because reasons is a dangerous game.
Plattsburgh, New York as of the census of 2010: “The median income for a household in the city was $28,846 … About 13.6% of families and 23.1% of the population were below the poverty line, including 20.0% of those under age 18 and 13.0% of those age 65 or over.”[0] The income levels in federal poverty guidelines [1] are pretty low so there are very likely a number of households in the city that are above but near the guideline. However, it isn’t necessary to get bogged down by federal poverty definition to acknowledge that some folks are going to have a hard time with unexpected energy bills.
For a while I worked as a manager of a program that helps low income households with their utility bills. I can tell you from experience that if a fixed income senior or low income family were to suddenly receive a utility bill that was $200 higher than they were expecting, they would face serious hardship. Even as a somewhat comfortable working family with two incomes, my household finances would be thrown into a bit of disarray if we suddenly had to pay substantially more per month for electricity and I wouldn’t be too happy as rate payer if that increase came with no benefit for me.
The utility can’t just decide on a new rate schedule and start billing it, they have to go through a process. The process for setting utility rates is typically a protracted and expensive affair. I am not as familiar with rate cases in the eastern states, but per the NY State website it looks like it takes about a year [2]. If folks can’t pay their utility bills now, it’s not going to get easier.
City leaders see that their neighbors are having a difficult time so it seems reasonable to put a hold on mining activities until they can come to an equitable solution. It is unfair to other rate payers if they are being asked to effectively subsidize mining activities.
[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Plattsburgh_(city)%2C_New_York... [1] https://www.federalregister.gov/documents/2018/01/18/2018-00... [2] http://www3.dps.ny.gov/W/PSCWeb.nsf/0/364D0704BEEC5B7D852578...