Schools Are Spending Millions on High-Tech Surveillance of Kids
gizmodo.com
gizmodo.com
Also for what it's worth "minority report" was the term in the film for when one of the precogs disagreed with the other two, so it's not really applicable here. You'd be forgiven for forgetting this fact though, because the plot doesn't actually feature one.
Why? Just skimming the page, it seems to be monitoring public social media posts for threats. Am I missing something? It's not like they're forcing students to grant access to their social media accounts so they can be monitored.
What happens when they start participating in denocracy. It's hard to imagine they'll have the same expectations of personal privacy after that.
Do schools still have libraries? They did when I went, and you can be sure they curated the set of books in the catalog and kept records of who checked out which ones.
If anything, more people reshare criticism more publicly than ever, even as they are being surveilled.
Admittedly, the difference is that our society thinks it's OK to punish kids and teenagers to make them get in line. That's the actual problem and the solution is not to have them hide their thoughts as much as to respect them more as human beings.
All it led to was a lifetime of learning how to improve my opsec and now I work in the field myself.
Continuous improvement!
Better to learn that lesson in school, when the mistakes that teach it to you will be confined to your juvenile records, than to learn it as an adult when it can follow you for the rest of your life.
When I was in high school, my history teacher complained that he wrote down "caracas" (the city) as his password on some form for the IT people, but they entered his password as "carcass", assuming that he'd spelled the word wrong. Which, of course, meant that he'd told an entire class his password.
https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Robbins_v._Lower_Merion_Scho...
Consider this excerpt from the article: "“Schools are justified in thinking about safety, both in terms of gun violence and other possible hazards,” Rachel Levinson, senior counsel at the Brennan Center for Justice, told Gizmodo. “At the same time, these technologies do not exist in a vacuum; we know, for instance, that facial recognition is less accurate for women and people of color, and also that school discipline is imposed more harshly on children of color.”"
Everything Levinson says here is vague and remarkably inarticulate. Being concerned is insufficient and a better written article would have asked Levinson further questions to clarify these claims. Precisely how is a bunch of data like this going to curb gun violence? What other hazards are you referring to, exactly? Why should we be concerned about the details of accuracy of the collected information while we're questioning whether it was ethical and useful to collect this data in the first place? Which school situations where "discipline is imposed more harshly on children of color" will be resolved by watching surveillance footage or examining location data?
All the more reason why people should get their own computers, never use school-issued computers, and make sure that their own computers run only a free software OS, and install nothing but free software on top of that. Also everyone (not just parents and students) need to politically organize to let students use privacy respecting books and (only if strictly needed) computer education that can be used from any computer OS.
Assuming the school district doesn't abuse it (like webcamgate) what's to stop every hacker from here to Moscow in this day and age?
With a public school you could just start shouting about the 4th amendment.
That said, do put electrical tape over the webcam and microphone.
For the camera, I can see it (pun intended) as electrical tape is usually opaque to visible light. But the microphone? All electrical tape should do over the microphone is lower the input level slightly.
⁽¹⁾ No jaywalking ⁽²⁾ Permit 38A required to hold children outside areas designated safe per § 477e of title XVI ⁽³⁾ Civil rights temporarily suspended