Hacker News Reader

Would you care to elaborate?

The mind consists of atoms and molecules. All of the physics relevant to chemistry is known [0].

[0] 10.1021/cr200042e

> The mind consists of atoms and molecules.

This is a type error. It's like saying the number 3 is made of atoms and molecules, or Wednesday is made of atoms and molecules.

You're gonna have to say a lot more to not beg the question here.

What question? It seems pretty clear what they are saying: the concept of mind is a social contruct, metaphorical, a figure of speech rather than a figure of physical reality.

The concept of a mind is not the same as an instance of a particular mind, any more than a algorithm is the same as a running process, or the idea of 3 is the same as a set of logic gates designed to represent a 3 in binary.

Mistaking our own internal representation of our own mind (our consciousness) for our actual mind is what Dennit is arguing against.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com