Incidinetally this is why I think Fusison/"Orders of magnitude better energy sources" (of which Fusion is the only viable one I'm aware of) are pretty much the most important thing for the overall continued stability of civilization.
Incidinetally this is why I think Fusison/"Orders of magnitude better energy sources" (of which Fusion is the only viable one I'm aware of) are pretty much the most important thing for the overall continued stability of civilization.
Um yeah, but until we have fusion which isn’t anytime soon, you’re proposing that we keep transforming energy, with losses at each step. In reality, where we have to live, and our energy isn’t coming from hypothetical sources, reconstituting plastic and reversing metal oxidation makes no sense at all.
But OP's point holds, all we are consuming is free energy (in the form of oil deposits, ore deposits, etc). And helium (in the form of gas, which escapes the atmosphere). Nothing else.
Instead, watch the atoms you learned about in chemistry class, which have the advantage of being real. They're generally conserved. (Not 100%, but places where we're changing atoms are very fringe in our economy.) Converting paper into a mushy mess is just introducing entropy into the paper. With energy invested we can turn those atoms back into paper. With our current tech level that may be a very long, winding, expensive journey, but it could be easier. Plus as we develop tech, we will start tending to prefer organizations of atoms that are easier to create in the first place, which is why you hear about things like the "diamond age".
With enough energy, we can rearrange atoms in almost any way we'd like. We don't dump things in landfills because we have no use for the atoms, we dump them there because it's too energetically expensive to undo the entropy introduced into them by our usage that has put them in their current high-entropy, low-use configuration. If we solved that problem, landfills wouldn't exist. That's a big "if", absolutely, no denying it. But if you, say, really passionately wanted to solve the landfill problem and not just nibble around the edges, this is the angle you should be taking.
- increasing automation in the recovery and processing steps
- increasing rarity of at least some valuable materials
- decreasing cost of renewable intermittent energy
Will make mining our landfills economically viable. Unless our society implodes earlier, which I hope it won't.
* we have a few hundred million years or so to find a new one before it becomes markedly less safe.
The difficulty us mere mortals have with sustained fusion is keeping the reaction from blowing itself apart (as in dissipation, not bomb). Gravity keeps things in check for free, but since gravity is so weak compared to atomic forces, you need an awful lot of it.
Our current containment solutions using electromagnetic forces require a lot of energy to maintain and so far, more than produced from the resulting fusion reaction.
Silicon, aluminum, iron, and concrete excepted, naturally.
And, yeah, this uses energy. That's why I mentioned accessible energy as one of the two things we do actually consume.
My best guess is that you didn't read the comment you are replying to, so I am hoping that repeating it in more detail, as I have above, will result in you reading it.