Tracing stolen Bitcoin, using a precedent from 1816
lightbluetouchpaper.org
lightbluetouchpaper.org
* poison: all BTC is the wallet is considered stolen, and all BTC in every wallet the BTC moves through from there is considered stolen
* haircut: BTC in the wallet is considered 30% stolen, and it's diluted as the money moves through other wallets
* FIFO (their solution): the first 3 BTC transferred from the wallet is considered stolen
But, the principle given in the paper is "nobody can give what isn’t theirs". Why isn't it the last 3 BTC transferred from the wallet that's considered stolen? The wallet had 7 legitimately acquired BTC to spend, so why isn't spending beyond that 7 what's tracked?
Someone could have a wallet or bank account (from the 1816 example) and not know stolen amounts were given to them. The first amount they spend should be considered legitimate.
If the first transfer in was 3 tainted BTC, it taints the first 3 out. If the first transfer in was 2 clean BTC and the second transfer in was 3 tainted BTC, it taints the 3rd, 4th and 5th BTC transferred out.
They don't seem to really have a way of measuring where the illicit value actually goes, so the comparison is just hand waving (in terms of forensics that's what tainting is for anyway, enumerating the accounts to consider; enumerating less accounts isn't necessarily an advantage).
The power of this method is directly proportional to how widely it's adopted.
And the reference to a precedent gives a false sense of legal legitimacy to this form of blacklisting. The decision referenced dealt with creditor claims to a shared asset.
The relevant legal precedent is from 1749. That's when a court sided with the Royal Bank of Scotland in its legal challenge to a request for a blacklist for notes used in crime. The RBS argument was that making money responsible for the acts of its previous holders would "render the Notes absolutely useless":
https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=2260952
For hundreds of years, that has been the legal treatment of cash, which has facilitated commerce, by making cash fungible.
Jurisdictions around the world have been steadily degrading the principle of fungibility over the last 40 years to institute a mass surveillance system to stop the drug trade, money laundering and income tax evasion (it's worth noting the income tax didn't exist in 1749).
The result is concentrated power structures accumulating ever greater bureaucratic control over the traditional financial system.
I think that concentrated power structures (that exist today or evolve in time) that can exploit this environment will win in the long run, but it won't necessarily be in any particular nation states interest.
[0] https://www.euromoney.com/article/b17jt5vnb3fn3m/g20-ministe...
Which of those resulting addresses contain tainted BTCs and which contain the clean ones?
A transaction such as the above would make it clear that the thief has control over the whole stolen wallet, but that's it. It doesn't mean that the recipient's addresses are thief's addresses, even though they could be. And we can't consider all of the end addresses as tainted, because what happens when the thief sends some of these to the address holding the silk road BTCs confiscated by the feds? Will they arrest themselves?
Whether that’s a fair allocation of the taint is a separate issue. They have a case, in some jurisdictions based on that precedent, that the law would support their allocation, and further that this treatment has other efficiencies.
It’s sometimes the case that laws are construed to be predictable, and easy-to-apply, rather than maximally ‘fair’ according to deeper subjective case-by-case analysis.
The FIFO (or LIFO for that matter) rule seems like an arbitrary chosen one which could easily be overcome: the thief can put the stolen funds in an address and only use those when the atomic swap protocol between chains is created, for example. Or exchange those funds on decentralized exchanges, or sell on localbitcoins.
This is an example of a transaction with multiple inputs, multiple outputs: https://blockchain.info/tx/1952ae67f75707e8a357cb40cc4e2123c...
The creator of such transactions can manipulate the order in both inputs and outputs.
The point of this FIFO method isn’t exclusively — or even primarily — to outwit thieves. Rather, it’s just to have a tractable (and legally-based) rule for deciding which balances, arbitrarily later, can be deemed ‘the stolen amount’.
Personally, I remain unconvinced that coins could be reliably traced through an "ideal" mixer service that moves a large number of coins between a large number of addresses via a large number of transactions.
Edit: A further requirement would be that the service would have to involve a large number of "legitimate" coins. This does disregard the possibility that the so-called legitimate coins would be considered illegitimate simply by association with said service.
That said, perhaps the difficulty lies in actually meeting such requirements.
That is, mixers work by not returning your coin, but rather someone else's coin. So if you mix stolen coin, you may get clean coin, but many others get dirty coin.
I have read that some mixers draw on freshly mined coin. But coin from users must go somewhere, right?
I never used crypto for illegal purposes, but I still don’t wish for people who receive coins from me to know the state of my main accounts.
Does that accurately model human behavior? Will it continue to once said humans learn of that technique?
2. deposit n stolen coins
3. withdraw n coins (clear)
4. settle loan with tainted coins
1. steal n coins from Bob
2. steal n coins from Alice
3. move these 2*n coins to the same addresse.
4. give n coins to Charlie: these are stolen from both Alice and Bob.
5. the remaining n coins are clean.
Then, after you've spend N coins, anyone looking for bob's coins sees you no longer have them. Anyone looking for Alice's coins sees they are still with you. This is because it is FIFO, so the outgoing transaction is only spending from Bob's coins.
1) It seemed to suggest that the increased precision given by this approach is somehow surprising. It totally isn't? I mean, the difference between taint-all (poison) and this approach is in the branching factor, you don't have to run the experiment to see the outcome?
2) The choice of FIFO is very weird (I don't really care about the case law.) For a given branching factor, surely there are numerous schemes that could be considered, and they don't seem to discuss the merits of any others. Off the top of my head LIFO seems to correspond much more naturally to intuition, but I think there is a better answer than that. If a untainted priority scheme was used, whereby tainted coins were always spent last from a given balance, then this would have the effect of keeping the taint as close as possible to the original thief, and separates the bizarre relationship between cash-flow and culpability that FIFO introduces.
http://thestudentlawyer.com/2012/04/17/a-critique-of-the-rul...
In the case, the funds transferred out of the account were treated as "dissipated" and thus unrecoverable. The case was about deciding between claims from innocent parties for money remaining in a mixed bank account, which is quite a different activity than tracing the flow of the stolen value.
FBIFO = first bad coin in - first out. Presumption is that bad coins are urged to be laundered first. So even if good and bad are mixing in - the bad ones ought to be first out
Say I have 10 BTC you transfer me 3 stolen ones I want to clean my wallet where do I transfer those 3 BTC and what happens to that wallet?
What happens when you don’t actually notice that it happened and try to purchase and item with your BTC? Do you get declined by the merchant because some % of that was tainted? If so how do you get that translation reversed?
This makes me think, what happens to fees? Suppose I take those 3 BTC and 'burn' it by creating a chain of 100 transactions, each with a fee of 10%? At the end, all of the stolen coins have evaporated into fees. Are those fees tainted?
If not, miners could try to white-wash coins this way.
It worked quite nicely, and we quickly reproduced what showed up in court... and with some fun extras. Combining the temporal (NOT 1816) and taint approach was a good way to trace the incident. Superimposing on regular (atemporal) taint analysis gives a broader view of the crime network beyond the individual incident.
As folks are noting here, tumblers and exchanges still make this a mess, even for 1816. They can go off-chain. However, those are generally where governments want to intervene anyways. Either way, we traced the full incidents, including how the silk road was moving money around, with our approach.
If you're into this kind of thing, professionally or for fun, let us know! Wouldn't be hard to repeat with more specific variants of 1816.
After all, some people will only accept coins that can be exchanged for fiat, and everyone prefers coins that everyone else will accept.
I'd be grateful if someone who's watched the video could explain what they're measuring, here.
With the new FIFO method, the tainting doesn't dilute as quickly. The give an example of a "theft of about 1000 bitcoins in 2014 and trace it forward to 2016", poison tainting and haircut tainting affect ~1.5 million addresses. With FIFO tainting, only 11,000 addresses are affected.
Any scheme like this is pointless without a mechanism to sanction the use of 'bad' bitcoin, and belongs in the realm of cryptocurrency regulation, not blockchain mechanics. A scheme something like this does exist for banknotes, in that if you are found to have a counterfeit bill, it will be confiscated. The only reason this does not have a stifling effect on the use of paper money is that the probability of this happening to you is slight.
imho poison is the ONLY method slightly acceptable.
with fifo it's all too easy to mislead the system with a honest transaction and now the vendor has the stolen btc, even though they delivered something in exchange for it and behaved honestly all the way.
edit: they measure total coins marked as stolen from begining to end of each tracking process, not correctness. as all the exchanged want is to have less poisoned coins to work with.
3 coin wallet containing 2 tainted coins and 1 clean coin
1 tainted coin and 3 coin wallet containing 1 tainted coin