Also doesn't microlensing involve gravity? Thus the effects of dark matter on microlensing would be identical to regular unseen matter which also interacts with gravity in the same way? What's the difference?
Microlensing involves gravity. The difference is that normal matter that could be dark matter would be relatively things massive but compact things like black holes and brown dwarfs as opposed to a diffuse halo. The compactness would make them detectable by lensing.
To my understanding, the two options you gave are the same: Dark matter is a hypothesized form of matter which does not interact with normal matter or light (i.e. It can't be seen).
According to my knowledge dark matter is identified through its gravitational properties. Matter and dark matter both are gravitational hence my curiosity on why we're identifying this unaccounted gravitational effect as "dark matter" rather than regular matter.