2, because you can sell that at election time. Politicians and courts are not technological experts but they're not necessarily as clueless as technologists like to imagine.
I have followed this particular issue for a good few years now and I can assure that people have been pointing out the negative side effects at length and in detail for a good longtime, but the political math simply doesn't favor the rational argument.
You know how crap political advertising is, so imagine your representative or senator voted against this because it was a poorly crafted piece of legislation. Next election season it'll be 'Senator Doe voted to protect child pornographers and human traffickers! Who does Senator Doe REALLY work for??! WHAAARRRGARBLLLLL!'
Expect more of this. Politics is increasingly not about good policy, it's about emotion and procedural tricks. No matter how well-intentioned, every politician worries about how their voting decisions can be (mis)represented at election time when voters are bombarded with bullshit claims that most have neither the will nor the time to properly evaluate.