Ask HN: Is there a name for the idea that there is no beginning to the universe? | Hacker News Reader

Ask HN: Is there a name for the idea that there is no beginning to the universe?

7 pointsmentos7 comments

I'm trying to find any further reading on the idea that there is no beginning or end to the universe and that things just exist.

It is only because we experience life through a 3D representation that we feel there must be some sort of start and end to things but I imagine that in some higher dimension things just simply 'exist'.

Anyone else agree or disagree with this and have any recommended reading for me?

View on HN

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cyclic_model

"World without end", and "Eternal Return" are two I know of.

Roger Penrose is in this camp and attempting to prove it. Although he does incorporate the big bang theory, which is a kind of a "beginning", I suppose. I would recommend his book, "Road to Reality".

You might gain more insight from ancient Hindu and Buddhist texts, but I can't recommend anything specific.

The three dimensions don't have much to do with whether there is a start or an end. It's really our perception of time that fools us. We traverse through time in one direction at a pace we can't control (much.) It's very unlikely we have the capacity to understand existence with our animal brainz

In addition to the cyclic model already posted about by noemit, there is "steady state theory":

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Steady_State_theory

I agree with the insight that being does not arise out of non-being; and being is not --and does not become-- non-being. Parmenides would be the first philosopher that comes to mind for this metaphysical perspective, but we only have fragments of his work.

You might be on to something, our inherent nature as human being, is to narrate things. Known as Narrative fallacy. maybe if we didn't care about the future, we wouldn't care so much about the past.

Lawrence Krauss’ “A Universe from Nothing” might be of interest. Can’t say I’ve read it but it’s on my reading list and sounds good, and exactly on topic.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com