The crude option is when 'undesirable' citizens will not be given credit cards, or if all their cards 'accidentally' stop functioning the same day to teach them a lesson. When no shop sells you food for money, your options are to beg, steal, or starve.
A more sophisticated option could be 'intelligent' credit cards that only allow you to buy approved stuff (otherwise the payment will fail); with the approval being general, or individual for each citizens, or depending on social class or whatever. This wouldn't happen overnight, but we can get there gradually... it may start by politically acceptable stuff like "you can't buy alcohol or guns using welfare money" and progress slowly.
- You want control to fight fraud/bad actors
- You don't want to much control for a single party (incl gov)
- It should work without necessary global communications (e.g. post disaster; global consensus like Bitcoin won't help there)
- Users want privacy
- Usual stuff like no double spending
- Transparency would be nice to verify correctness and no abuse by your bank
- Easy to use
We'll have a hard time finding a replacement satisfying them all. I wonder what we'll be willing to give up.
"But I have nothing to hide! I don't want to buy illegal stuff!"
Not right now, maybe. But who decides what's illegal and what's not?
A cashless society is one more step towards turn-key fascism, which is why it has to be opposed.
Also worth noting is that the chairman of the central bank of Sweden basically told the banks to stop whining and continue handling cash.
When I go to a bar or a McDonalds I pay cash for this reason.
I feel confused that you have this very accurate description of a problem ("companies sell your personal data") and your solution is "we must hide from the companies" instead of "we must enact laws to restrict dealing in personal data".
Facebook used contracts instead of technical controls to protect data, and we've seen how well that worked :)
I'll admit many on HN are obsessed with overly technical solutions, but "using cash" seems much simpler than "establish a complex regulatory regime".
Technical measures can also be effective, but they usually suffer from the problem that each individual must know about the threat, must know about the technical solution, and must use that solution, which usually requires some effort. I see very few people arguing that health inspectors ("policy") should be abolished and every individual should be responsible for not eating at unhygienic restaurants, even though there are technical solutions one could use that would allow someone to mitigate risks in such a scenario.
No. The default is that what I spend my money on is no one else's god damn business. It doesn't matter if I spend it on puppies and charity and unicorn dolls, or if I spend it on dildos and drugs and hookers.
And it's incredibly important for society to progress, that everyone can choose to spend their money on things that are illegal, things that are unethical, things that are on the edges, things that are subversive, because economic activity is the best indicator we have of what society values.
Clinging to an old and limited system because more technically advanced options seem hard and chalenging is a luddite attitude, whatever way you turn it. The way forward is not to go back to cash, but to find or build a better alternative.