Currencies either have value from
1) Being made of a commodity (e.g. gold coin) or exchangeable for the commodity.
2) Because someone says so. This is "Fiat". Usually this is a government, not not necessarily so. See "company scrip" for another example.
Lack of an issuing government does not magically create a backing commodity.
Being unable to use a banknote (e.g. a 2008 Zimbabwe 1 Trillion Dollars Banknote) doesn't make it any less Fiat - no commodity has appeared; it makes it low-quality fiat money.
So what does it make them then? As far as I know, the categories are "fiat" or "commodity-backed". If it's not Fiat, which commodity backs Chuck-E-Cheese coins?
Or is it merely backed by the say-so of the Chuck-E-Cheese company? You understand that "say-so" in Latin is "fiat"?
Isn't this just a form of "Company Scrip", a (low quality) Fiat instrument?
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Company_scrip
https://thebluecollareconomist.com/2016/10/30/fiat-currency-...
No government or other monetary authority has said that cryptocurrencies are legal tender in their country, or has required that anything to be paid in cryptocurrencies. In fact, many governments say it is a commodity.
of course "because someone says so" is an oversimplification of fiat; they need to do so believably which is why the United States of America has the resources to do it but I would not be able to.
Company Script is generally illegal these days, which is instructive - you need to distinguish between "it's impossible to have fiat money without government regulation" (false) and "it's illegal to have your own fiat money because of government regulation" (generally true). Nation-states even sometimes fail at fiat money, so regulation is understandable.
Bitcoin looks like something that has value only because people agree that it does. Saying that "bitcoin is a commodity" means what exactly? This trivially copied pattern of bits is a scarce resource? Proof of work is valuable in itself?
This is actually an interesting way to analyze it. The trust created by PoW apparently does create value to many people.
How much would you pay for an hour of video of me digging a hole with a spade and then filling it in. That's proof of work, and also worthless.
How much would you pay for someone to provably burn ton of coal? It's only valuable if it does something useful for the energy expended.
The blockchain's proof of work has been characterised as "Computers yelling Numberwang at each other" and what use does it have outside of itself? It burns huge amounts of of energy to produce waste heat and a trivial hash.
As for current market cap, IMHO it means less than you think. See also: bubble, pyramid scheme, ponzi scheme.
It means that the government does not legally consider it any kind of currency, fiat or otherwise. It's taxed like a commodity when you buy and sell it. It's not legal tender.
If we're using "commodity" to refer to an useful substance like wheat or silver "a product of agriculture or mining" ( https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/commodity ) Then I would disagree, bitcoin does not fit this definition, the value of bitcoin is an agreement, nothing more. "Agreement" and "because we say so" seems a lot like fiat to me.
https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/fiat
Most cryptocurrencies have value because of a mutual belief that they have value, but the overwhelming majority have not been mandated for use by some authority yet.
So, "they have value because we agree that they have value. Because we say so".
That's exactly "Fiat".