How the “focus on first” helps hide Google’s relevancy problems
searchengineland.com
searchengineland.com
Oddly enough, I like it that Google isn't going to return only things that a given field's experts like. It's good that it's possible that if you hit enough criteria, you can be one of the top search result even if you aren't what the authorities like. It keeps things interesting.
What’s happening is that Google rewards longevity. AltaVista was around ages ago, gained a lot of links over time, and in particular links from other aged sites.
Again, I think it's good that Google is using the Internet's memory. Searching is seeking information. Altavista might just be the term for information on search engines with the most discussion around it. Maybe it's the "best search engine" but perhaps my searches for "search engines" isn't about that but rather about how a search engine is built, how people interact with a search engine or what-not. There, the memory of the Internet is crucial.
If every search for X becomes "what is the best X in the world", the Internet will be rather diminished.
After all, if they made it to Google's first page of results, so they have to be pretty good at SEO to get high results for the search for SEO... right?