You can't trust blindly the previous studies because they may be wrong, or have hidden assumptions. A well known case is the use of a control group. If you want to study a new drug, you must compare the results of the patients with a similar group that is taking the previous drug and/or a group that is taking no drug. You can't just trust that the cure rate of the previous study is 23.573% and compare it with your results. (And there are some trick to get more reliable results, like using a placebo instead of no drug, and doing a double blind study.)
How are you going to reproduce a study about a cancer drug? Synthesizing the drug itself is a huge endeavor, never mind finding a group of participants with the exact cancer you need. How would you reproduce the Large Hadron Collider experiments? You'd need to rebuild one of the most technically challenging, most expensive scientific instruments ever made.
Our problem isn't lack of resources. There's 7.5 billion people in the world, I can't believe we've ran out of control groups and experiments to do. Maybe it's a little more difficult with medical edge cases, but there's plenty of other things to research. It's just hard to do it politically, especially with people that are "anti-science", meaning against funding research that might show outcomes that aren't good for them economically, or against their religion.
You must have a totally different definition of "the scientific model" than I do. I suspect (although I could be wrong) is that you have an oversimplified view of just what the scientific process is.
The scientific model/process is not a linear list of discrete steps moving from "Ask a question" to "Communicate results"; it is not a discrete and static set of criteria we apply to individual experiments or instrument output.Berkeley University does a good job of providing visualizations on this topic:
Back in early science days, this used to be a valuable section because the pool of "scientists" was huge and they often crossed disciplines. Now you have all sorts of specialties such that the pool of colleagues who are able to understand and assess your work might be, like, 8 people.
There was a Japanese mathematician who recently put out a huge proof that claimed to solve a major math problem (I am forgetting all of the important details here, so forgive me). The news wasn't so much that he created the proof, but that they couldn't find anyone to verify it!