Hacker News Reader

Comment by rdlecler1 | Hacker News Reader

Children under 2 can fly free on a parents lap, but my wife insists on buying our 4month old his own seat for safety reasons. There will be zero chance I talk her out of this now.

View on HN

Some (not all) car seats are also rated for use in aircraft, and they have some notes about that on the label. We planned for it, so both of ours were, even though they were enormous. I humped them into and out of every flight when our two kids were small. The flight crews never complained.

Its basically the difference between seat belts that work, and seat belts that don't work. There's plenty of space in between perfect landings and crashes that kill everyone onboard. Seat belts matter in that in-between space, as today's incident shows. For us, the peace of mind was totally worth it.

Edit: The FAA's pamphlet on the topic. Its quite readable, despite coming from a regulatory agency. https://www.faa.gov/documentLibrary/media/Advisory_Circular/...

Infant in lap is supposed to be secured with a seat belt that attaches to the parents seat belt. They are not unrestrained.

However, an infant is much safer in a car seat strapped to their own seat of course.

That requirement, if it exists, is either pretty new or must vary by airline and/or by country. I've flown multiple times with small children not in their own seat, within and to/from the US, on various US-based airlines, within the past ~5 years, and that was never a requirement.

That is not the case in the U.S., we had an unpleasant (and highly patronizing) conversation with an airline steward who tried to tell us that FAA regulations prohibited such a seat belt and that "the safest place for an infant is in their mom's arms".

We were looking at this this morning. Apparently they (WestJet) will refund you the cost of the seat if you provide proof of age up to a week later. I assume this may only apply if your child is close enough to 2 that they feel a need to verify, and you don't have proof of their age with you.

WestJet website doesn’t say anything about this. Actually mentions purchasing a seat as an option but no refund. Any update on this or with other airlines?

There is also zero chance of the same situation presenting itself again in our lifetimes. It's much better to invest extra money to protect ourselves from things that are likely to occur, like car accidents.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com