As a non-astrophysicist, just scanning the wikipedia entry [1] it appears to me that gravitational microlensing studies must be fiendishly difficult, you probably need massive amounts of data and of compute power to get to highly confident conclusions. Is my impression accurate?
If that is so, than the MACHO theory should not be discredited that quickly. It is after all the only theory that does not require any new physics in order to explain the missing mass.
[1] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gravitational_microlensing