Futhermore, all interstate freeways are built with federal investment, and HUD is heavily involved in funding development of low-income housing nationwide -- this is also subject to staggering amounts of NIMBYism. Mass transit is even worse -- there are major American cities who want to build, and have lined up federal funding, only to be blocked by state government intervention on behalf of more NIMBY. Baltimore's Red Line is the most recent example of this that springs to mind.
So yes, this is very much a problem for city and state politics to solve -- the federal government can't invest without their cooperation.
As for comparisons to Asian cities, I can only thank God that we don't handle our development that way here. Our rural residents have enough problems without repeating the mistakes of India here.
Japan's suicide rate is not significantly higher than that of Finland, Argentina, and the USA. South Korea is the one developed Asian country that has a notably high suicide rate.[1]
And yes Japan's population is shrinking and aging, but that is mostly a rural/inaka phenomenon. Tokyo is actually growing in population and manages to have lower rents than SF, NYC, London, and HK. Not to mention a meticulously run rail system that puts the NYC MTA to shame.
[1] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_suicide...
While I’m sure you can find anecdotes about elders turning to petty crime, I can find anecdotes of people not doing that in Japan. It’d be pointless. What I can do however is provide a chart of crime in the US vs crime in Japan, but then you may as well look at just a US crime chart since Japan’s line would be imperceptible.
Reminds me of the cheeky MCAS Beaufort slogan, "The Noise You Hear, is the Sound of FREEDOM."
Australia really has 2 major cities (Sydney and Melbourne), and two second tier cities (Perth and Brisbane).
I think it's also in part to how separated the federal government is from local governments. In Australia, tax money is collected by the federal government and then disbursed to the states (bit of a simplification). There's less of a clear delineation between "federal money" and "state money".
The Tokyo metro is famously 30% of the population of Japan.
It'd be like LA having nearly 100 million people.
The Moscow metro is 11% of Russia. The NYC metro is 6% of the US by comparison.
Germany's two largest metro areas - Berlin and Ruhrgebiet - have a comparable share of its population to NYC at around 6%-7%.
Stockholm is 23% of Sweden. London is nearly 21% of the UK. Paris is 18% of France. Toronto is 16% of Canada. Mexico City is 16% of Mexico. Madrid is 14% of Spain. Amsterdam is 13% of the Netherlands. Bucharest is 12% of Romania. Rome is 12% of Italy. Jakarta is around 11% of Indonesia. Lagos is 11% of Nigeria. São Paulo is 10% of Brazil.
Amazingly, the Shanghai and Beijing metro areas are close to or sub 2% of China.
But this is like saying "Phoenix is 23% of Arizona", which is also true. (Arizona and Sweden have roughly comparable populations, though Sweden is a bit larger.)
Just going by ratios I would expect the US to have 26 Tier 1 cities.
I would also expect the US and Europe to have roughly the same number of Tier 1 cities, since they have roughly the same population.
I agree that the federal model of the US (which cascades down and has similar boundaries at the county & city level) is probably one of the root causes. Having "NSW Police" versus 482 city police departments in California is just one of many examples.
By contrast, the NYC metro area has around 6% of the population of the USA.
But it's also about bulk number of large cities. If the federal government wants to inject funding into a large city in Australia, they have 2 options. You can't really play politics there, especially since Sydney and Melbourne have similar political makeups.
Europe's population is around twice that of the US and the EU itself has around 50% more people than the US, so that is not an entirely accurate statement.
https://www.oftwominds.com/blogjuly10/suburbs-defense-07-10....